In many ways being a twin can be a lot like being in an abusive, unhealthy relationship.
Imagine you have this person in your life that looks exactly like you, wears their hair similar to yours, has the same circle of friends, and everything down to their voice, their gait, their mannerism’s all almost identical to your own.
And what’s even more frightening is your own thoughts, aspirations, that little voice inside your head telling you right from wrong, good and bad, even your fears, insecurities – this person has them too.
It should feel like an invasion of privacy but you become so used to this person in your life that you can’t imagine a day without them. You base your morals and sense of worth and accomplishment off them. Living without them is unthinkable. All this is extremely unhealthy when you’re an adolescent trying to figure out who you are. It seriously complicates that process of becoming your own person.
While this is all extremely pessimistic, make no mistake – losing this person is even more unhealthy. You lose so much of what you are and are left disorientated. This is how I felt when my brother committed suicide in 2009 when we were 16 years old.
But I have found positives in the death of my brother. It gave me something I had never had before and always craved – a sense of individualism. It forced others but also me to see myself as my own man. Unexpected surges of relief would hit me for the next few months after his death and I was not sure why. I felt guilty to no end. The shame of that feeling was unspeakable and I could not even admit its existence to myself, let alone to anyone else.
For all the conflicted feelings my brother’s death brought though, I came to conclusion that both grief and death give people a lot more than we give them credit for. Alongside the sadness and confusion, so many strings were cut when my brother died that I now feel unrestrained to do as I please without fear of copying or being copied, without that crushing feeling that I am no more than two of a kind; without that feeling that my actions and thoughts, my whole being, are entirely restricted and pre-destined to what my genetics determine them to be. I no longer have that ‘control group’ and it feels amazing.
Grief is not a competitive sport; I make no amends for how I feel. I do not wish to be the most bereaved person in the room or to justify to the world why my insides aren’t dark and depressed 100% of the time. I am strong and hard inside, but can also talk openly about my emotions. I am empathetic and emotionally secure. And the thought of losing people close to me is not feared. When grief eats me up and makes me choke on my own thoughts, when tears are slowly dropping from my eyes, as depression is looming over me, I think about him. I am washed away with an overwhelming sense of warmth and gratitude. That’s when it feels like my brother is so close to me again.
Michael is a guest on this week’s episode of Insight, 8.30pm Tuesday on SBS, which explores what twins can tell us about ourselves, and humanity at large. You can watch a snippet of the episode below:
If you or a loved one is looking for mental health support/assistance, we urge you to contact Lifeline on 13 11 14 or visit the website.
Top Comments
As an identical twin myself, I can relate to much of what he says in struggling for your own identity in adolescence. It was other people and their perceptions/behaviour that I found more difficult than actually having a twin. "You can't do this or that because how will it affect your twin?" The labels- "the pretty twin", "the smarter twin", "the more outgoing twin"- non stop comparisons that were infuriating and stupid. My family persecuted my husband for throwing me a surprise birthday party once- although I was not close to my twin at that time, my twin didn't actually care at all, and it was three weeks before our actual birthday it was still deemed "unacceptable" to have a party that was just for me. The arrogance in assuming you have the right to tell a twin how they have to live their lives, or making up "rules" they have to adhere to escapes them. My twin and I have lived very independent adult lives and are glad of each other now (we are good friends) but I didn't enjoy adolescence as a twin really (and I'm pretty sure she didn't either). Everyone's experiences are different and it depends on many other factors (such as family dynamics and personalities). I don't think anyone else should judge David's viewpoint or decide whether he has the right to feel the way he does. Unless you walk a mile in someone's else's shoes, you don't know. I'm extremely glad my twin sister didn't commit suicide and I still have her, but I understand David's comments and I'm sure my sister would too.
That was disconcerting. Some things, sometimes, are better left unsaid. I hope your parents don't read this.
Huh? It's not like Michael was saying "my brother was a a-hole, and I'm glad he's dead". Michael quite clearly stated that he's been conflicted by David's death, but there have been some positives from it. Doesn't mean that he doesn't miss and grieve David.
Bottling things up isn't healthy. I'm glad Michael shared this, because he's gotten it off of his chest.