It's 2008.
In theatres, a film called The Reader, produced by Harvey Weinstein, and a film called Vicky Cristina Barcelona, written and directed by Woody Allen, are box office successes.
But there's another movie everyone's talking about: 27 Dresses, starring Katherine Heigl. Written and directed by two women, it tells the story of Jane, who has somehow served as a bridesmaid 27 times. She's in love with a man who instead falls in love with her sister (even though James Marsden is single and right... there), and we watch as she wrestles with the idea of having to stand by her sister's side on the wedding day.
I would like it on the record that 27 Dresses gave me an entirely unrealistic idea of what my 20s and early 30s would look like. Surprisingly, I have not been a bridesmaid 27 times, and I definitely haven't attended an underwater wedding, a goth wedding, or a Gone With The Wind-themed wedding.
Nonetheless, aside from the unbelievable opening scene where Jane attends two weddings in one night (the stress... I just can't), 27 Dresses was relatively unproblematic as far as movies of the 2000s go. Especially given the names behind the films that opened alongside it.
Watch: Katherine Heigl on being labelled 'rude'. Post continues after video.
But by the end of 2008, it would be Katherine Heigl - not Harvey Weinstein or Woody Allen - who would be frozen out of Hollywood.
Her crime? Being unselfconsciously, unflinchingly... honest.
What is the Katherine Heigl controversy?
In a profile for Vanity Fair at the beginning of 2008, Heigl was asked about the decisions of her character Izzie Stevens in the top-rating medical drama, Grey's Anatomy. Breaking one of the unspoken 'rules' of stardom, she acknowledged the commercial considerations that often come with writing for prime-time television.
"It was a ratings ploy," she said of a recent dramatic story arc involving her character. "It was absolutely something that shocked people; it wasn’t predictable, and people didn’t see it coming. It’s our fourth season; there’s not a lot of spontaneity left. And business is business; I understand that, but I want there to be some cooperation between the business end and the creative end, so there’s some way of keeping it real."
Later in the interview, Heigl was asked about her 2007 film Knocked Up, directed by Judd Apatow, which had catapulted her to a new level of fame.
"It was a little sexist," she told Vanity Fair. "It paints the women as shrews, as humourless and uptight, and it paints the men as lovable, goofy, fun-loving guys. It exaggerated the characters, and I had a hard time with it, on some days. I’m playing such a bitch; why is she being such a killjoy? Why is this how you’re portraying women? Ninety-eight per cent of the time it was an amazing experience, but it was hard for me to love the movie."
But it was a statement released by Heigl later that year that did irreparable damage to her future in Hollywood.
Having won an Emmy for Best Supporting Actress for her role in Grey's Anatomy in 2007, she was expected to be nominated for the award in 2008. Instead, Heigl pulled out.
"I did not feel that I was given the material this season to warrant an Emmy nomination and in an effort to maintain the integrity of the academy organisation, I withdrew my name from contention," she said.
"In addition, I did not want to potentially take away an opportunity from an actress who was given such materials."
Listen to Mamamia's daily entertainment podcast on Katherine Heigl’s villain story taking an unexpected turn.
Do Katherine Heigl and Shonda Rhimes have beef?
The decision was understandably interpreted as a criticism of Grey's Anatomy creator, head writer, and executive producer Shonda Rhimes.
From that point onwards, rumours about Heigl's on-set behaviour dominated gossip pages, and her reputation suffered.
Speaking to David Letterman in 2009, she was asked about the new season of Grey's Anatomy.
"Our first day back was Wednesday," she said, "and it was - I’m going to keep saying this because I hope it embarrasses them - a 17-hour day, which I think is cruel and mean."
Days later, sources said it was actually Heigl's fault the 17-hour day had to happen in the first place.
"Poor Katherine Heigl," said journalist Ken Levine. "What she neglected to add was this: This 'cruel' shooting schedule was only to accommodate HER and her needs. The producers graciously shuffled things around so she could go off and do promotion for her new film. Also, with union rules, the producers had to pay a ton of overtime and penalties to make this happen. The thanks they get is Katherine Heigl going on national television hoping to embarrass them."
Katherine Heigl was subsequently cancelled.
Despite the damage to her reputation, Heigl was still starring in big-budget films alongside some of the most well-known men in Hollywood. There was The Ugly Truth in 2009 with Gerard Butler, Killers in 2010 with Ashton Kutcher, and Life As We Know It the same year with Josh Duhamel.
But in March 2010, Heigl reportedly didn't show up for work on Grey's Anatomy. Shonda Rhimes reached an agreement to release her immediately from her contract, and Izzie Stevens never returned to the show.
In an interview with Oprah Winfrey in 2012, Shonda Rhimes said Heigl's statement about the Emmys had "stung".
"On some level, it stung and on some level, I was not surprised," she said.
"When people show you who they are, believe them. I carry that with me a lot. It has served me well."
In the years since, Rhimes has been more forthcoming about her experiences with Heigl. Speaking to The Hollywood Reporter in 2014 about her new show Scandal, Rhimes said there were "no Heigls" on set.
"I don't put up with bullsh*t or nasty people."
That same year, Heigl addressed rumours that she was 'rude', during an interview with talk-show host Meredith Vieira, which has recently resurfaced.
"I've heard rumours that you're very rude - what are your thoughts?" Vieira asked the actor in 2014.
"You know what, I've been saying I don't think I am, but I'm going to be really honest right now: I'm not," Heigl responded.
"I know I'm not. I don't need to think about it. I'm not a rude person, I'm not an unkind or mean person. I would never go out of my way or consciously hurt anyone's feelings or make them feel bad or uncomfortable or not be professional and do my job - I like my job."
Heigl went on to say she would "continue to stand up" for herself.
"I'm not going to stop standing up for my right to be heard, my right to be treated respectfully and professionally in return, my right to draw boundaries. I am a strong woman and I'm not going to apologise for that."
Two years later, Heigl's Knocked Up co-star Seth Rogen spoke on the record about feeling "somewhat betrayed" by her comments about the film.
"As we were making the movie, honestly, I was like, 'I would make a dozen movies with her,'" he said in 2016.
"People seemed to like it," he said. "We were funny together. I was having a really good time, and then when I heard afterward that she didn’t like it, that she seemed to not like the process, and she did not like the end product either, I think when that happens - also your trust feels somewhat betrayed."
Heigl later apologised for commenting publicly.
Heigl had burnt bridges, and her career would never recover. In 2011, she appeared in New Year's Eve alongside Zac Efron, Michelle Pfeiffer, Hilary Swank and Sarah Jessica Parker, but it received harsh reviews. Her next film, One for the Money, released in 2012, bombed at the box office and earned her a Golden Raspberry nomination for Worst Actress.
The next few years saw two more Golden Raspberry nominations and several film and television roles fade into obscurity.
In 2016, Heigl apologised for her comments about her Grey's Anatomy Emmy nomination, saying she was "embarrassed".
"I shouldn't have said anything publicly," she told Howard Stern. "But at the time, I didn't think anybody would notice. I just quietly didn't submit and then it became a story, and I felt I was obligated to make my statement."
A Katherine Heigl renaissance.
In recent years, there's been a reassessment of how the media reported - and how we interpreted - Heigl's behaviour. A 2021 feature in The Washington Post headlined 'Katherine Heigl is Done Apologising' argued that "maybe, just maybe, the Heigl backlash outweighed the crime".
"In a post-#MeToo world, in a post-Trump world," the author Ashley Spencer questioned, "is it not laughable that so much grief was given to a woman for speaking her mind?"
In 2022, Ellen Pompeo, who portrays Meredith Grey, addressed Heigl’s 2009 claims about the intense work hours on Grey’s Anatomy.
"I remember Heigl said something on a talk show about the insane hours we were working, and she was 100 per cent right," Pompeo said, speaking to co-star Kate Walsh, on her Tell Me podcast.
"Had she said that today, she'd be a complete hero. But she's ahead of her time, made a statement about our crazy hours and, of course, let's slam a woman and call her ungrateful."
She continued: "She was f**king ballsy for saying it. And she was telling the truth. She wasn't lying."
In 2024, Heigl appeared on stage at the Primetime Emmy Awards with her Grey's Anatomy castmates Ellen Pompeo, Justin Chambers, James Pickens Jr., and Chandra Wilson to celebrate the show's nearly 20-year run. She said it was the first time she had seen many of the cast in more than 15 years.
Even with more than a decade of hindsight, most of us have a visceral response to Heigl's behaviour: Don't criticise a trailblazing woman of colour for not doing a good enough job at writing the show you got an Emmy for. Don't call out the writing on your own show as being a "ratings ploy". If your own schedule was to blame, don't describe a 17-hour day as "cruel."
But is it not telling that our response to an outspoken woman, who doesn't just sit down, shut up and follow the rules, is to classify her as 'rude', or 'entitled', or God forbid, a 'bitch'?
Is it not telling that that last label is the very worst thing a successful woman can be? That it's an attribute that cancels out the myriad other parts of who she is, and makes her entirely undeserving of everything she's achieved?
In 2024, Heigl still wishes she kept quiet.
Almost 20 years since Heigl's career took a nosedive, she's opened up about being cancelled.
She specifically mentioned the comment about the Emmy, saying that she didn't "feel [she] was given the material this season to warrant an Emmy nomination".
On Shannen Doherty's Let's Be Clear podcast, she said she never actually turned down an Emmy.
"Well, I didn't [say no to an Emmy] and everybody keeps saying that. I didn't turn it down," she said.
"You know, you have to submit yourself. You have to submit your work and then they deliberate and then they decided if they want to give you a nomination. I just didn't submit my work that year."
The starlet elaborated, saying that in retrospect she wishes she said nothing.
"I should have just said: 'Oh, I forgot', because it created such a maelstrom that was so unnecessary – I was kind of trying to make a bit of a snarky point about my material that year but I was also just not feeling my material," she explained. "I didn't think I had anything that warranted even the consideration for a nomination. I just wasn't proud of my work."
She added that she would "never be so bold or so arrogant to turn down a nomination."
"I just knew — there wasn't anything that would really warrant tone that year. And I was trying to be honorable I guess. I was trying to have some integrity. I wasn't trying to be a d*ck."
Heigl's reckoning feels unfair, in light of other Hollywood revelations.
The story of Katherine Heigl is an uncomfortable reminder of the double standard that exists not only in Hollywood but in the social world more broadly. Because while Katherine Heigl seemingly had a black mark against her name - in the industry and with audiences - from 2008 onwards, it would be a decade before people like Harvey Weinstein and Woody Allen would be interrogated.
Even now, men with truly disturbing histories are regular fixtures in the movies and TV shows coming out of Hollywood. But 'difficult' men are forgiven in a way 'difficult' women aren't. Their transgressions are part of who they are, not the whole. They're allowed to be socially inept and funny, a philanderer and a romantic, a control freak and a genius.
But after 2008, Katherine Heigl wasn't afforded the luxury of being anything other than rude.
And she paid for it with her career.
For more from Clare Stephens, you can follow her on Instagram, or listen to her podcast Cancelled here.
Listen to Cancelled: Mamamia's comedy podcast about what happens to celebrities when the world turns on them. Post continues after audio.
This article was originally published on April 28, 2022, and has since been updated.
Feature Image: Getty/Instagram @katherineheigl
Calling all Holidaymakers! Complete this short survey now and go in the running to win one of four $50 gift vouchers!
Top Comments