So the Beer Mat Mum (BMM) is home. I must say, I’m relieved. As, no doubt, are her family. Journalist Andrew Dobb wrote about this story for Crikey last week, questioning why it was such huge news here, landing BMM on front pages around the country.
He writes:
The Daily Telegraph’s headline on Tuesday summed up the tone with “Beer mat mum faces Thai jail hell.”
As we all now know, Smoel received a suspended sentence and a fine of just $40. She walked free from court and is reportedly on her way home this morning. The sentence was a mile away from the potential “five years in jail” mooted by the media over the last week.
So why did the media get so worked up about Annice Smoel?
.Admittedly the story did have a few elements that the media was always going to find irresistible. The novelty beer mat angle was too cute to ignore. The fact that Smoel happened to be blonde was a bonus, as were her four doey eyed kids. The media quickly adopted Smoel as a sort of everywoman. She became one of us, a fun loving Aussie, held captive to those merciless westerner-hating officials in one of those corrupt and dirty places in Asia and ergo she must be championed.
When the media discovered Smoel was speaking out and that what she was saying contained that wonderful blend of anger and vulnerability, she became a sensation and everyone started taking notice.
But it was the prank element that became the clincher. Not only was Smoel one of us, a mother, with her beer mat, tearful kids and quavering voice, she also happened to be innocent. At that point the media flicked the switch to outrage.
…..The elements of this story have been predictable from the start. The jail, in which Smoel spent two nights, was described by the media as “four metres by four metres”, as if that suggested a torture cell out of Apocalypse Now. The toilets were described in graphic detail, the food was condemned as inedible and the officials were described as heavy handed.
Even an instance of incorruptibility on the part of the Thai officials was twisted to suit the story. On Tuesday, the Daily Telegraph wrote “The family have admitted they offered Thai authorities money to secure her release but it was refused.” Written like this it is merely an indication of our beer mat mum’s desperation, and certainly not of the wrongdoing of offering what appeared to be a bribe.
When Smoel gets off the plane today it’ll be hugs with crying kids and tearful joy at being home in the best country on earth and, if all goes to script, a vow to never go back there again.
About the only line that suggested something other than the “innocent abroad” theme came in Karen Percy’s report from Phuket on ABC TV this morning which ended with this tag: “But (the whole affair) has also shone a spotlight on the way Australians behave abroad.”
Obviously the death of Natasha Richardson was a far greater tragedy in every respect but there is a parallel there for me that accounts for such immense public interest in a story – you immediately think ‘what if that was me?”
The idea of her kids at home distressed….the daughter who had to have surgery without her mum…..it was upsetting stuff.
I must say I missed the part where it was all a beat-up about “Thai Jail Hell” and the idea that Asian countries were dangerous places with ‘un-Aussie values’. That hadn’t really occurred to me.
You can just imagine the call from K-Rudd to the Thai Prime Minister “Mate, look, this isn’t going to be a good thing for tourism. Can’t we sort this out?”
And they did.
Top Comments
Gig, your attitute towards this story, and your indignant defense of your opinion really highlights a dangerous ethnocentric attitute that needs to be stamped out of Australia.
I can only laugh at your assumption that Thailand relies on the Aussie Tourism dollar to survive, and your opinion that Thailand is a third world country.
To say that Thailand should basically make exceptions for Aussies because we are Aussies, well that's just the kind of ridiculously ethnocentric attitute that got Annice Smoel in trouble in the first place.
Interestingly enough, the bar owner, the one who called the police- is an expat Aussie.