If “sharenting” is a selfish and dangerous activity, then my Facebook feed is full of terrible humans.
For example, this morning, I launched the app and saw:
A former colleague’s toddler falling asleep in their car seat, mindlessly cramming crackers in her mouth.
A hospital shot of a newborn wrapped in the ubiquitous pink-and-blue blanket of a labour ward.
A video of a work friend’s toddler in a nappy, playing drums on dad’s head.
My own son and daughter rumbling with their uncles on a weekend visit.
I’ve seen the first words and first foods of children I have never met.
I’ve seen toddlers looking sad in hospital, little girls splashing in the backyard pool. Accidental swears. “Hilarious” backyard stacks.
"Sharenting" is what we do now. And apparently, we have no idea how dangerous and dumb it is.
So said the excellent writer Angela Mollard this weekend in a column for News Ltd that aimed a barb at one of the great sharenters of the modern age, Zoe Foster Blake.
In case you have been trapped under something heavy, here's a recap: Zoe and her husband Hamish Blake both have busy, red-hot careers. She's a beauty guru/writer/business owner. He, according to Zoe, is a tap-dancer, but you might know him as one half of Hamish and Andy. They are parents to Sonny Foster Blake, who is two and almost unreasonably cute.
Sonny features large in Zoe and Hamish's social feeds, which have a combined following of 1,107,000 people on Instagram.
A dedicated army obsess over his adorably-mangled pronunciation of words like "favourite" and come together to Share and Like every new missive from his parents (Sonny does not have his own social feeds, unlike Roxy Jacenko's much-followed daughter Pixie Curtis, or several of my friends' under-fives).
Top Comments
I love seeing photos of the children of friends and family and love that social media allows me to share events I otherwise wouldn't. But this story has raised issues that I think are worth considering. Privacy of the child is obviously one. As parents we feel we have the right to share any images of our children and I have seen arguments that suggest our children will be happy to have a full record of their life. That of course could be done in a photo album so of itself is not, in my view, enough of an argument. And, at some point, our children may start to feel embarrassed by their history being publicly available, which they've had no control over. There is also the argument around whether by posting, we're modelling good behaviour - because we're showing our kids how to post appropriately - or bad behaviour - because we're teaching our kids that life is not lived unless it's been seen to be lived by a large group of other people.
It's this last issue that troubles me the most. I've seen parents praise their kids' achievements publicly on Facebook, which I've no doubt has been done out of real pride for their achievement. But, is it necessary, and, is it in our children's best interests? Are we teaching kids that unless our lives and achievements are validated through a display on social media they are worth less, or that a parent's praise is worth less because the parent didn't say it to the world at large? We may argue that that's not what was intended and we're just trying to share a special moment with people, but I'm not sure that's always true.
For myself, I now question myself before posting anything about my children and ask, who would find this interesting, who did I think about when thinking of sharing the photo and what are my motives for sharing? I've found that for the most part now, I share photos with specific individuals by text.
great response - totally agree!
I disagree with embarrassing our children publically in any way. My personal rules for sharing photos and stories online is to only share content that glorifies my kids and presents them in a positive light or shows them at their best. I don't post embarrassing or humiliating content or caption pictures of them crying over seemingly silly things and I don't post pictures of them naked, and I never share private information about any medical conditions or disabilities.
The day either of my children ask me to take their pictures down is the day it will all come down.. and if my child asks me not to post something, I don't.