You need to be celebrated.
You know what’s harder than disagreeing with your boss?
Disagreeing with your boss when he’s the most powerful man in the country.
That’s why, today, we’re name-checking the growing number of Coalition politicians who’ve announced they will defy Tony Abbott by supporting marriage equality — even though the Liberal party room this week voted down a free vote for ministers.
Related: Who is Warren Entsch? We’re glad you asked.
It all started with Warren Entsch, the 64-year-old Liberal National MP who spearheaded the cross-party bill to legalise gay marriage. The Queensland MP has today confirmed in a News Corp interview he would “absolutely” cross the floor — that is, vote against approved party lines — should the issue come down to a vote.
Then this morning, Liberal MP Wyatt Roy announced he, too, would defy Prime Minister Tony Abbott to support Entsch’s bill.
“I’m from a very socially conservative Queensland electorate but I told my constituents when I was first elected, I’m for same sex marriage and nothing will change that,” the member for Longman told Buzzfeed News.
Asked specifically whether he would cross the floor, Mr Roy responded: “I feel quite comfortable doing that.”
Mr Roy’s announcement comes after openly gay WA senator Dean Smith vowed to cross the floor in support of Entsch’s bill to amend the Marriage Act.
Mr Smith yesterday told Fairfax: “In contemporary Australian society, it is no longer defensible for the state to deny proper and equal recognition of a marriage between two consenting adults, simply based on their sexuality.”
Top Comments
*Toe the party line, not tow.
I'm getting sick of this. We can't have a MEANINGFUL referendum about marriage equality. It's not about which would be more or less likely to be carried. It's about the basic uses of each thing. Referendums are only held to change the constitution and, although marriage is mentioned in the constitution, changing it to exclude gender as a criteria is not a constitutional issue.
'There had been doubt about whether this federal power over marriage could be used to recognise same-sex marriage ... In striking down the ACT's recognition of same-sex marriage in 2013, the High Court held that the federal marriage power can authorise marriage between people of the same sex.'
(Remember, they didn't need a referendum to alter the marriage act to add that appalling phrase to the marriage ceremony).
Furthermore, in 2012, Tony Abbott understood full well that this is not a constitutional issue.
;Mr Abbott said "questions of marriage are the preserve of the Commonwealth Parliament".
"Referendums are held in this country where there's a proposal to change the constitution," he said.
"I don't think anyone is suggesting the constitution needs to be changed in this respect."
The only option is a plebiscite, for all the good that will do. While we don't know how much a plebiscite would cost, the 1999 referendum cost $66,820,894. Adjusted for inflation, that would have been $103,588,254.75 in 2014. It's also non-binding and it would STILL be up to parliament to actually legislate this change so it's nothing more than a ridiculously expensive, non-binding, opinion poll.
It's interesting that Tony Abbott wasn't throwing around words like "plebiscite" (or referendum, come to that) in 2004 when the Howard government changed the marriage act. Tony Abbott wants to bury marriage equality and plebiscite will push the decision back by years. It will also allow the absolute worst of the anti-marriage groups free reign in a way that they haven't done to date. The Irish referendum has given us a taste of how that would go.
It's also worth noting that Australians are notoriously bad at "carrying" (or passing) referendums - and I doubt plebiscites will be much different.
'Australia has held two national plebiscites, in 1916 and 1917, relating to the introduction of conscription during the First World War; both were defeated ... Since 1901 there have been 19 referendums, proposing 44 changes to the Constitution; only eight changes have been agreed to.'
I suspect that Tony Abbott likes those odds.
http://www.smh.com.au/comme...
http://www.aec.gov.au/Elect...
http://www.abc.net.au/news/...
http://www.peo.gov.au/learn...