By MAMAMIA TEAM
In a fashion spread by photographer Annabel Mehran, Vice magazine has attempted to sell clothes through glamourising the suicides of famous female authors.
Vice magazine are well known for trying to ‘push the envelope’ with their fashion shoots. But this sick attempt to sell clothes by making suicide look ‘edgy’ and ‘sexy’ is a whole new level of distasteful.
This also comes on top of previous fashion shoots from other brands that seek to glamourise prostitution and homelessness. And it makes you wonder how far the fashion industry will really go to sell an outfit.
So, who were the famous authors whose tragic deaths Vice have used to try and get you to buy some frocks?
Well, their first salesgirl is Virginia Woolf, whose long struggle with depression was so beautifully portrayed in The Hours by Nicole Kidman. Among Woolf’s classic novels are Mrs Dalloway, a book which deals with themes of suicide and A Room Of One’s Own, which is generally seen as a seminal feminist text.
Woolf committed suicide by drowning, in 1941. She wrote a farewell letter to her husband, filled the pockets of her overcoat with stones, and walked into the River Ouse. Woolf was plagued by a deep, dark and tragic depression. And yet in Vice’s fashion shoot, a model made up to look like Woolf stares languidly into the middle-distance.
Virginia Woolf, in the final moments of life, has been turned into an object. Into a passive clothes horse.
Vice’s
Top Comments
http://imperfecthope.tumblr...
I wrote about this on my blog, link above. And it's not what you would think.
I'm willing to get shot down for this.
Hi TessGirl,
First of all, bravo for your honesty! The thing is, I think a lot of people, and especially fellow depression sufferers, agree that it is not the photos themselves that are offensive, but their purpose. Stand alone, it is perfectly acceptable for people to see them as beautiful, painful, maybe even a way of creating awareness. However, associating suicide with the fashionable is not acceptable. Mental illness is not a marketable commodity, and it is here that the problem lies. For example, it is only the advertising purpose that seperates the image of Virgina Woolfe from any other depiction of her depression (e.g. Nicole Kidman's beautiful portrayal of her struggles in The Hours). If the images were art, they would considered an exploration of mental illness that most people would not find abhorrent. However, the fact is that they were not created as art. Another objection people have had is that some of the women depicted have died as recently as 2004, with families, spouses and children still living and grieving. I certainly hope the magazine had their permission. I think it is perfectly acceptable for you, and anyone, to react to the images in anyway they feel! It is their purpose that should be scrutinised.
Spot on Anon!
These are not art, they are adverts mocking these beautiful tragically depressed women.
Yeah the idea of going "ooooh is love a pair of those noose-stockings" is so, so wrong. There's art, and then there's shameless money grabbing
What an awful 'creative' idea! Tasteless and tacky :(