My daughter Grace passed away in September 2010.
There wasn’t an obituary. There wasn’t a funeral. There wasn’t a casket or even a body to put in it. No one sent me sympathy cards. No one brought me casseroles. But that wasn’t because no one cared. It was because my child was still alive.
When my daughter came out to me as transgender at age 12, I was driven by fear. I feared that my child would kill herself if she couldn’t begin her transition from my daughter to my son.
That fear and longing to save my child overtook everything else. I forged ahead into a new life and helped her transition. I didn’t expect to feel such grief. C.S. Lewis said, “No one ever told me that grief felt so like fear.”
I had to put away all the girl pictures. I had to get rid of any sign that Grace had ever existed. I had to remember to call my child by the name that she had chosen: Chris. I had to replace “she” with “he.” I had to start calling the child I thought was my daughter my son.
I distinctly remember crying one Saturday afternoon in bed, mourning the loss of my daughter. Grace came in and hugged me. “Mum, if this is going to be so hard for you, I won’t do it,” she said.
I looked into her eyes and saw such fear. I knew that she needed to transition to alleviate the pain in her heart. But she was willing to keep going through that pain to spare me pain. I thought about what a great kid I had, and about the fact that what I loved was her heart and soul, not her gender. “No, I know you need to do this,” I said. “And I’ll be OK. Just give me time.”
Top Comments
If only we could bottle that kind parenting, love and open mindedness this world would be heaven on earth.
I don't think I could be more pro diversity than I am, more accepting of difference, more into raising awareness. I am all of those things but I am also the mother of a child who has died. As in, dead, not alive, never coming back in this life time. One I did get to plan a funeral for. People brought me lasagne, mostly. Lucky me!
I don't usually do the comparison thing. We each have our own cross to bear but how dare this writer make any comparison to her child having died, HOW DARE SHE. As parents, at some stage, to varying extents, we have to let go of the 'ideal' child we thought we would have and hopefully embrace our children for who they actually ARE. Our children become who they are because of us and in spite of us. Sometimes you are hoping for a girl after having three boys. Sometimes you want your son to become a footballer but he is into ballet. Sometimes your daughter likes boy bands when you'd prefer her to enjoy classical music. I am not trying to trivialise the loss and grief this mother must have felt but at the end of the day she still had a child who she was supporting to be the best he could be. A child who has a long, happy life ahead; fingers crossed. One she gets to watch grow and develop, laugh with and cry with. One she gets to hold in her arms and watch graduate and fall in love.
Even an analogy such as 'Welcome to Holland'
http://www.our-kids.org/arc...
regarding special needs children would have been offensive in this instance but reproducing this article, with it's extremely poor comparison, was bad judgement indeed.
Read my story here:
http://whatkatedidnext.word...
Then ask yourself how many 'happy tears' I've shed.
Please put more thought into your story choices in the future to maintain your previously high standard.
I havent gone through what you have but I had very similar thoughts after reading the heading and then the article. Ridiculous
Me too. I thought I was being overly sensitive.
I don't have children but I thought the same thing as soon as I started reading the article and realised it had nothing to do with the actual death of a child.