If our children are overweight, should we talk to them about it? Or is it better to spare them the shame of the f-word? It’s the dilemma plaguing modern parents.
The New York Times has flagged new research that gives us an answer: do not talk to your kids about weight.
We’re often told that we should be open with our kids about everything. That it’s much better to prepare them for the brutality of the “real world”, which has no place for sensitivity. But what happens when our attempts to “toughen up” our kids makes it harder for them in the long run?
What the research tells us
Although we mean well, trying to get our kids to lose weight is a touchy subject. There’s a fine line between gently encouraging them to exercise and making them think that they’re fat.
The study, titled “Don’t eat so much: how parent comments relate to female weight satisfaction”, is from the journal Eating & Weight Disorders. It shows that parents’ comments are often much more harmful than they think.
It’s such a difficult subject for any parent. And often, it feels like a tug-of-war between their mental and physical health.
Researchers asked 501 young women between the ages of 20 and 35 questions about their body image. They also asked them to remember how frequently their parents made comments about their weight. The women who remembered their parents’ comments said they felt the need to lose a significant amount of weight.
Top Comments
The other thing that I believe can be damaging is even talking about your OWN weight and diets in front of children... Because then if they perceive you as perfect in their beautiful eyes & then see you hating on themselves they can start seeing their own "flaws"
My parents yoyo dieted my entire life and now ALL of my siblings & I have weight & self esteem issues even though they never once told us we were overweight etc.
For eg: If you see them at a size 10 saying they feel or look fat what's that child going to think when they become the same size?
I disagree. Parents, mothers should talk to their daughters about weight. But just saying 'you're fat' is not helpful. All children should understand that having a 'jelly belly' means they are not eating enough of the right foods and not moving enough, and that its harmful to their health. Labelling is about as useless as having free dental checks. But what to do? Explain that childhood is a great time to do something about it, prevent further fat cells laying down, and use growth to help and that its Mummy's fault not theirs, and help them to get more exercise and to increase their vegetable and fruit intake, and reduce their biscuit, fruit roll, yoghurt, and 'lunchbox treats' and crappy sugary cereal intake. Usually its just too much sitting and sugar/starch and crap food right? And if they're a kid living at home, then whose fault is it? Start cooking with them, help them build a healthy bento lunch, and don't take them shopping or avoid the middle aisles. it's a family thing. But they must know that they're carrying too much stored energy and need to use it.