Science. Sometimes it can be really annoying.
US paediatrician Howard J. Bennett has just written a piece for the Washington Post shattering the myth that sugar makes kids hyperactive.
“It doesn’t,” he says bluntly. “Lots of scientific studies have been done to answer the question, and they have all reported the same thing: Sugar does not make kids overactive.”
To be honest, this is old news. More than 20 studies in the early 1990s proved there is no link between sugar and hyperactivity. But one study, in particular, showed how strongly parents cling to this belief.
The study brought together 35 boys, aged from five to seven, whose mothers claimed that sugar made them hyper. The boys were split into two groups, with one half supposedly fed a big dose of sugar and the other half fed a placebo. In fact, all the boys were fed a placebo. The mothers who were told their sons had been fed sugar kept a closer eye on their sons and told them off more, then claimed their sons were way more hyperactive. Interesting.
Nothing to do with the sugar. Sorry. Image via iStock.
But back to Bennett. He says kids tend to eat lots of sugary foods at events like birthday parties, where they get to play with their friends in a fun environment.
"It's the party atmosphere that makes them hyperactive, not the sugar," he asserts.
Bennett adds that because people have been linking sugar and hyperactivity for decades now, it's become accepted parental wisdom, even though it's not true.
Top Comments
Urgh. This old chestnut. The actual issue is the quick spike in blood sugar followed by a dramatic low when one consumes high GI food. This can have an effect on mood, memory and concentration.
My kids suffer a distinct meltdown about 20 minutes after consuming sugar, then they are feral until bedtime. The kids eat sugary treats or processed snacks only extremely rarely, and not just at parties where excitement could be cause. I call BS on this research - sugar industry research grant anyone?
I'm thinking that too. Even in adults eating a chocolate bar will give you an quick rush of energy followed by a crash. It seems realistic to expect a similar up and down effect in kids, and considering they are much more emotionally that adults I can see that resulting in crazy unmanageable behaviour.