It’s fine. Really. It is completely fine with me. And here’s why.
My friend to her small child: “Excuse me? Don’t be rude, give Avi a kiss hello.”
Me: “It’s okay, I don’t mind, she doesn’t have to.”
My friend: “Did you just hear me? You don’t want to be a rude little girl.”
Eventually, the kid gives in. Comes over and gives me a hug or kisses me on the cheek. And I feel terrible.
It’s not that I don’t want to hug my friend’s children, or my nieces, or chubby-cheek babies. I do. I really do.
It’s just…welll…there are multiple experts who say making a child to do something with their body (even a simple hug) when they don’t want to teaches them that they have no control over their body. That adults do.
Peter Saunders, chief executive of the National Association for People Abused in Childhood, says "Children should never be forced to do anything which makes them uncomfortable around [their body]. Children are instinctive and intuitive around people they are not comfortable with. And we need to respect that."
Of course you want your child to be polite. I understand.
And in our society, being polite means touching someone when you greet them. Whether it is a handshake for a new person, a side-cheek air-kiss for a friend, or a full body hug for family. And truth be told, sometimes I don't even want to touch people when I greet them.
But when you ask a child to do it, and they don't want to - because say, they are in the middle of drawing a Picasso-esque drawing - and you tell them to do it, you may be teaching them the wrong message.
You may be telling them that their thought of not wanting to do something doesn't matter. And THAT right there is the code that I don't want to interfere with just because of a greeting. THAT code is the little voice inside them that will alert them to trouble when you aren't around to protect them.