I am a big fan of inappropriate humour (especially when said humour is tinged with sarcasm), and I’m an even bigger fan of using comedy to deal with life’s ugliness.
But when the humour is at the expense of someone unknowing and innocent – say, a child – I no longer consider it funny.
One day on Twitter, I came across Sh*tty Mum, whose moniker is from the book series of the same title. The books are intended to be comedic, in-your-face parenting guides for imperfect mothers.
What I noticed from the Twitter page, though, was that a lot of the jokes were more offensive than humourous.
Who am I to get offended? After all, I don’t have children - a fact that my estranged mother will tell you gives me zero authority on anything parenting-related - and my babysitting experience, as extensive as it is, still pales in comparison with the childcare required of a full-time parent.
However, I do know what it's like to have a narcissistic parent.
I know how it feels to be viewed as an annoyance or burden by the person who should (ideally) love you unconditionally.
Tracy Cassels, founder of Evolutionary Parenting, writes, “Perhaps it’s just not funny to view your child as a burden, a pain in the ass, or the enemy who ruined your life... When you view your child that way, your parenting is going to reflect that.”
Even if pressed, my mother couldn’t tell you my favourite colour or my favourite food, but she will tell you how selfless her parenting was, and how ungrateful I am as a child.
One excerpt from the book Sh*tty Mom For All Seasons goes into great detail explaining how to dispose of your child’s “garbage” without your child knowing.
Artwork, according to Shitty Mum, is mostly garbage, because your child isn’t as talented as they think: “By second grade, his glue blobs still looked exactly like glue blobs. Along with his poor skills, he also held on to an unrealistic faith in the nexus between garbage and genius.”
Is parenthood bad for creativity? Post continues below.
My estranged mother encouraged me to express myself through art, but only as long as it didn’t inconvenience her in any way.
When I was in kindergarten, I made and illustrated a book about my family as part of a class project. I drew a picture of my mother with a caption that read: My mum’s hair is red, like her temper.
My teacher thought this was hilarious, even showing it to other teachers throughout the day, but my mother didn’t find it humourous at all.
After that incident, I shied away from expressing myself truthfully, out of fear that I might hurt her feelings.
I was a child of the latchkey generation: Like most of my friends, I understood the sacrifices my parents had to make in order to put a roof over our head.
For those who were raised at intersection of Generation X's “get over it” and Generation Y's “express yourself” these conflicting messages resulted in the inability to tell your story without feeling guilty about it.
This guilt is infinitely compounded when your parents reject everything you create as a lie, or turn your story into their own somehow, without a thought to how such behaviour could affect you - their child.
Last month, Maggie May Ethridge wrote an essay titled “How I Became That Mom Breastfeeding A 4-Year-Old.” It wasn't centred around the topic of breastfeeding - rather, it was a touching story about how she listened to her daughter and discussed her daughter’s needs honestly.
More than one critic in the comment section attacked Ethridge for being self-serving, or for abusing her child by breastfeeding past the “socially-acceptable” age.
But what struck me was how she tuned into what her child actually wanted, and respected her needs.
I never expected my parents to embrace all of my hobbies or interests, but I did expect them to listen, to pay attention.
Sh*tty Mom for All Seasons also advocates any type of activity that distracts your children, whether it be over-feeding them or sticking them in front of the television. This may be necessary for working parents who need a break, but Sh*tty Mom goes a step further in explaining how much of a time-suck children are:
There is no worse feeling in the world than knowing you’re about to spend the next three months with someone who thinks American Girl dolls were invented for mothers and daughters to play together.
I never expected my parents to embrace all of my hobbies or interests, but I did expect them to listen and pay attention to me.
Even if pressed, my mother couldn’t tell you my favourite colour or my favourite food, but she could definitely tell you what kind of parent she was (selfless) and what kind of child I was (ungrateful).
She doesn't know my favourite book or author, but she can tell you that I have “no right” to comment on parenting, and that I remain childless not of my own choosing, but because of some kind of karmic punishment.
The Sh*tty Mom movement provides a support system for imperfect parents. I’m sure those with families who put the “fun” in “dysfunctional” can find loads of humour in the material.
But for those of us who are still trying to heal from a difficult childhood and toxic parenting, the jokes aren’t funny.
This story by Diana-Ashley Krach originally appeared on Ravishly, a feminist news+culture website.
Follow us on Twitter & Facebook and check out these related stories:
Top Comments
The picture you drew as a child probably hurt your mum's feelings. Obviously, you're not responsible for that as a child, but with the benefit of hindsight, maybe you can have some empathy.
You're mother "not knowing your favourite colour/food" is an example of her being a crappy mother? Did she not feed you, clothe you and encourage your artistic pursuits??
I doubt my mum knows what my favourite food is/was. She and my dad raised me, fed me and looked after me, but she is her own person with her own life and I don't expect her to be a saint or be an expert in all the minute trivia of me - how self obsessed!
Do you know your mum's favourite food/ colour?? Now that you're a gown up, maybe you should try treating her like a person and not just your mum.
I mean this in no way as an insult, but to open your eyes to the possibility of your seeing another view: I think your reaction to the Sh-tty Mom thing is exactly like that of your mother when she reacted to the picture you painted of her when you were little. No sense of humor.
I know it's hard, but try to see when you're being like her so you can grow from it. You are resentful and angry.