Dear friend,
I have sat quietly during these past 5 years and picked at my already-damaged cuticles, while listening to you hold court with our mates and bemoan the state of modern politics. I haven’t spoken up. I haven’t pushed back.
I have quite literally bitten my tongue (and that bloody hurts by the way) while I watched you insult politicians who I admire and ideas I have faith in, all in the name of dinner party conversational popularity.
But I’m done with my politeness now. Because last night, you went too far.
While lazily reclining on a deck chair in Newtown, you claimed that metaphorical soapbox with your usual zeal and you were, quite simply: a bit of a dick. In a backyard full of bleeding heart lefties, you thought you’d distinguish yourself, prove you’re just that much more outrageously progressive than the rest of us.
And so you had a go at Barack.
In the spirit of a hysterical contestant on America’s Next Top Model, please imagine my finger being waved in your face right now, with my head moving sideways on top of a stationary neck: “Oh no you dinnit.”
But it wasn’t that which pushed me over the edge, it was what came next. As you took the field for a quick game of your favourite sport – trashing the Labor Party – you said that the Americans’ excuse for progressive politics was no better than Australia’s and there was nothing worth celebrating in Obama winning a second term.
You said we shouldn’t hope for a Gillard victory in Australia to follow on from Obama’s in the States because what difference would it make anyway? She’s not a real progressive you ranted. The Labor Party are a mess you cried. Things wouldn’t change that much if Tony Abbott became Prime Minister?
Top Comments
Although non-constructive criticism/whinging is worth calling out, i think you've been a little too harsh. I mean, surely we can expect more than water, basic infrastructure, services etc.
Yes, there are lots of people in the world that are worse off than us, but by that logic, it would be unreasonable to be critical of our conditions unless they were at least as bad as those in the worst place on earth. Doesn't leave much room for progress.
And besides, i would argue that one of the failings of the moderate left is their weak efforts (or no effort) to change the situation in those countries. Increasing foreign aid, onshore processing of refugees, and better effort at dealing with climate change to name a few.
I know not all of these things are possible immediately, but isn;t it the job of progressives to push hard for these things? Culture and social license has to develop too.
I will be voting at the election, but i hope that everyone who cares does a lot more than that.
Didnt this article run a couple of weeks ago?
Perhaps you could give us an article of what is happening in Irsael & Gaza, explaining the history of the conflict & possible outcomes & how it effects us?
Hi Jackie,
Yes - this article ran early last week. We posted it again because we realised lots of people aren't able to read Mamamia during the week and the weekend is their time to catch up.
And on Israel and Gaza - there's something in the works. Watch this space.
Lucy