According to actress Emma Thompson, you can’t be a great mum and keep working all the time.
Oh man, really? What the shit E.T.?!
Maybe she hit her head before the interview? Perhaps she was taken out of context?
I read this statement, recovered from the series of small strokes it induced, and then sought out the original Daily Mail article so I could better understand her line of thinking. After all, Emma Thompson is a goddess of epic proportions, a champion of working mothers everywhere, and a bloody great actress.
Upon further investigation things only got worse, Emma actually said: “I wanted to spend more time with my family. A year off was my birthday present to myself. I didn’t actually act or write. I was just a mum. I taught drama at my daughter’s school, cooked meals and had fun. I highly recommend others to do the same if they can afford it. You can’t be a great Mum and keep working all the time.”
Oh my Christ. So many emotions, which one to go with? Teaching drama?! What? I can’t even. You can’t even. She can’t even!
I think Emma Thompson’s good mother checklist goes something like this:
1. Ensure children’s emotional, physical and spiritual needs are met at all times. (Private family yoga sessions are involved here.)
2. Ensure house is always tidy and smells of lavender. (I don’t know why I went with lavender, it just felt inherently British.)
3. Feed children home cooked organic and nutritionally balanced meals. (With all fruit and veg grown in her own environmentally sound patch that the servants planted when she was being a bad mother.)
4. Perfect parental attendance of all child activities and sports. (Thank GOD the Range Rover fits seven!)
5. Impart Oscar winning wisdom on method acting to the next generation. (Ring Daniel Day Lewis. See if he is free for morning tea.)
Of COURSE Emma needed a year off to be a good mum – look at her list!
I think it comes down to one simple fact here, my definition of a ‘good mother’ vastly differs from Emma Thompson’s.
Let us focus on that fact, rather than Emma forgetting she was not addressing a convention of millionaires who find things like cooking, mothering and chores to be a quaint novelty.
You see, us working mothers are a sensitive lot. I don’t know about you but I am constantly scanning conversations, emails and other people’s inner dialogues for a hint of someone insinuating I am not measuring up as a mother.
Okay, I don’t really do that but I am ‘she’s a bad mother’ sensitive, because deep down my darkest fear IS that my children somehow suffer because I work. I mean, they would suffer a great deal more if I didn’t (in the form of starvation, hypothermia and general abject poverty). I don’t really have a choice; as I am sure many of you don’t either.
Top Comments
I am a shift worker so my days off vary every week. My kids are 14 and 10 years old and they are always excited when I tell them I am not working in the morning. I know they would love me to take a year off, they would thrive and I think the 14 year old would be the one that benefited the most. It's not just the little kids that need you....
I think you've missed the point where she said 'all the time.' I don't think she's saying all mothers need to take a year off like she did, just that if you're working all the time you'll miss out on being as involved in your kids' lives as you would if you weren't working all the time. Same goes for dads. My husband works all the time - leaves the house with barely a hello for the kids, gets home when they're in bed so only has time for a goodnight. Works in the evenings, works on weekends. When he's not working he's knackered. He'd be the first to admit that, due to working all the time at the moment, he's not the father he wants to be to his kids right now. Emma Thompson was talking about herself and mothers but the point could just as easily be made about parents - if your work takes over your life, if you're working all the time, you can't parent your kids as you would if you had a bit more balance.
Okay, I just reread the quote and she does advocate a year off if possible. Well, I still think it's nice to hear someone publicly advocate staying home with kids because mostly what we hear is that women must stop staying home with kids and get back out and earn, contribute to the economy, never mind that they're part of the multi-billion dollars of unpaid care work that goes on in our society. Well once in a while it is a lovely surprise to hear someone recognise the contribution mothers - parents - can make to kids' lives if they're around more often.