couples

Is it normal that... I told my son that he was really bad at this?

I told my son he was terrible at trombone. But please, let me explain myself.

He has only just started trombone this year. To choose it as his instrument he had to do a ‘blow test’. He received top marks so was allowed to choose whatever wind instrument he wanted. He chose trombone, but his arms aren’t yet long enough to play it properly. His band instructor still let him choose it on the assumption he would grow soon.

This wasn’t my idea. I suggested he choose the trumpet because he could already hold it and it came in a much smaller container, way more convenient for bringing home on the bus.

Unfortunately Philip decided the trombone was what he wanted. He does like to bite of more than he can chew and then chew like crazy. So I bought the ridiculously expensive and incredibly large instrument (thank goodness for the rent-to-by scheme). He’s been playing for exactly one term. They have band training for around an hour once a week and then he is meant to practice at home every single day.

On the day of my unfortunately direct assessment of his ability, Philip had not yet practised at home once. I was a bit annoyed because he chose the hardest and most expensive instrument possible. Where was his commitment?

He arrived home one Friday after band training and said, “Mum, I’m the worst trombone player in the whole of training band”. I said, “Yes you are a terrible trombone player but that’s because you never practice, so get it out and practice!”

ADVERTISEMENT

From that day on he’s been practicing for 10 minutes every day, better than nothing, and every so slowly improving. It still sounds like the very loud breaking of wind but at least he’s making an effort.

I’ve always wanted to be the kind of parent who tells their child the truth. Whenever I watch talent show auditions of kids who are obviously very bad and singing or whatever it is they do, I blame the parents who probably told them they were amazing and next they they knew, their child was embarrassing themselves on national TV.

Philip will never think he’s good at something he’s not but I’m make sure he knows exactly how to get there. Plus, he’s good at so many things he took my criticism in his stride.

He gets very frustrated with himself sometimes. It can be hard to learn something new. I just remind him of how hard he found it to draw Spiderman when he first started and now he is an expert at it, because he used to do it for hours every day. Then we looked up funny trombone player clips on YouTube and found this one, of a trombone player sneezing during a very formal concert.

It’s one of the funniest clips we’ve ever seen. Talk about embarrassing.

What do you think? Is it okay to tell your kids that they’re no good at something?