A mother from Alabama has been permanently injured during her labour after a nurse held her baby’s head in her vagina until the doctor arrived.
Caroline Malatesta and her husband, JT Malatesta, have been awarded a $16 million (USD) in damages, after a jury found Brookwood Medical Center at fault for medical negligence and reckless fraud.
It was 2012, Caroline Malatesta was pregnant with her fourth child and she decided to give birth in the new hospital because they had advertised a flexible approach to natural birth plans.
The hospital had birth tubs, birth balls and wireless foetal monitoring so mothers could walk around during labour.
“When I first walked into my room, I was told by my nurse, ‘You need to get on your back in the bed for monitoring and you may be there for the rest of your labour,'” Mrs Malatesta told AL.com.
“That raised a red flag.”
The mother said she had spent time talking with her doctor about the importance of wireless monitoring and mobility, but the nurse did not facilitate the plan.
“He was not just on board; he said that was the safest thing for me and my baby,” she said.
Despite attempts to get more comfortable, she said she was forced on her back. As her baby was crowning, Malatesta got on her hands and knees.
“The nurse told me to get on my back. I stayed on my hands and knees and breathed, trying to relax, as that is what came naturally to me. But the nurse pulled my wrist out from under me and flipped me over on to my back,” The 36-year-old told Cosmopolitan.
Top Comments
That is terrifying and so upsetting. That poor woman! I can't imagine the distress and pain she would have felt, and is still feeling.
omg I am having my first in 6 months and I would yell and and my partner would crash-tackle these f**kers before this would ever happen. I think a lot of first timers in particular naturally feel pressured, vulnerable or intimidated to speak up when this stuff happens. That could have additionally caused the baby irreversible damage too. I have read that some medical staff have told mothers having uncomplicated normal deliveries to stop pushing so that the baby isn't born before the doctor can arrive. Not because of safety and wellbeing for the mother and baby but to cove their own asses in for malpractice. Well, it sure backfired here! Poor woman.
This makes me doubly want to find a doula, something we thought we might do.
I can't encourage you more strongly to get a doula; they're wonderful. And not because they are going to prevent something like this happening, which is very rare, but because they can be worth their weight in gold in helping you achieve the sort of birth that you can walk away from feeling positive, whether that might be a natural birth, or an emergency caesarean. I can't recommend them highly enough :)