Trigger warning: This post deals with domestic violence and may be distressing for some readers.
Tasteless fashion shoots are nothing new, especially not for Italian Vogue, which published a controversial blackface editorial earlier this year.
But this month’s cover shoot – which pictures beautiful, vulnerable-looking women wearing the likes of Balenciaga, Miu Miu, Fendi and Marc Jacobs and screaming as they’re threatened with guns and knives – really turned our stomachs.
And worst of all? Is the magazine’s claim that the shoot of horror movie victims is somehow intended to “raise awareness” of violence against women.
Mamamia has always been a strong advocate for domestic violence discourse, and of course we’re all for starting a discussion about this pervasive issue, even through non-conventional means.
But there are other ways to achieve that aim than perpetuating the stereotype that says there’s something cool, edgy and arty about showing women mutilated, frightened, covered in blood, or threatened with weapons. And that’s just what the images appear to do: reinforce the status quo, not challenge it.
Top Comments
A psycopaths wet dream is hardly a statement against domestic violence. 'Pain is ephemeral' - till the next time. Ludicrous as a fashion spread and pure hubris to connect this set of images to the persistent reality of violence against women.
To me the images look less like domestic violence and more like "the guy with the unnerving stare who follows me home from work just broke into my house and wants to kill me and dissolve my body in a tub of acid but not before taking my left pinky as a souvenir". I don't quite understand why it's gotten everyone up in arms.
The magazine's statement also sounds like something that they've just come up with because people are taking offence to a fashion campaign that is macabre rather than the standard sexualised. Some of the images come across as the woman being the violent one rather than the man. Why haven't the men got up in arms about violence towards them? Because it's not an awareness campaign, it's not a magazine making a statement. It's just a fashion shoot.