A woman was executed in Saudi Arabia this week. The decision has angered human rights advocates – but in an example of gross hypocrisy, it has also angered the woman’s home country of Indonesia.
Siti Zainab was beheaded on Tuesday in Saudi Arabia after being convicted of stabbing and beating her employer to death in 1999.
Nainab’s story is deeply tragic. Advocates argue that she was a maid who killed her cruel and abusive boss in self defence. Amnesty International claim that Zainab was mentally ill and for that reason alone it was against international law to end her life. But Saudi Arabia was undeterred and executed her on Tuesday.
Zainab’s execution didn’t just anger human rights advocates. It has also upset the Indonesian Government who have called in the Saudi ambassador to explain why their citizen was executed.
The Indonesian Government’s outrage is certainly an appropriate action of a country whose citizens are imprisoned and sentenced to death overseas – but in light of Indonesia’s repeated insistence on executing foreign citizens themselves, their objections seem hollow and deeply hypercritical.
It’s cold comfort for Bali Nine duo Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran and their families who are enduring a nightmarish wait for the firing squad on “Execution Island” that Indonesia is prepared to stump up for their own citizens, but continue to refuse mercy to Andrew and Myu.
Indonesia has successfully won reprieve for nearly 200 of their citizens facing execution for drug offences overseas. And the Indonesian foreign ministry said recently that it was currently seeking to prevent the execution of at least 229 Indonesian citizens overseas. The country reportedly paid millions of dollars to stop the execution of an Indonesian maid, Satinah Binti Jumadi Ahmad, who was facing the death for murder in Saudi Arabia.
Top Comments
You have to understand that the concept of hypocrisy, so abhorrent in Anglo culture, isn't a big issue in some other cultures. What we do for 'our' people is different for what we do for 'other' people. How is that so very different to most humans' thinking?
More than 105 million Indonesians live on less than US$2 per day. An Indonesian woman is 30 times more likely to die in childbirth than an Australian woman and one in three children under the age of five suffer from stunting, caused by malnutrition. About 120 million Indonesians do not have access to safe drinking water while about 110 million do not have adequate sanitation. Because of this Australia provided $581 million in aid to Indonesia in 2013/2014, yet they can afford to spend millions of dollars to save one person from execution and hundreds of thousands of dollars on the circus that has been the farcical trial and prisoner transfer of Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran?