Years ago, when Shane and Simone Warne broke up, they lived together for a while as separated husband and wife, to maintain some stability for the kids.
It was something I noticed, despite only being in my early twenties, because I knew first hand how difficult moving between the houses could be for children of divorce. So I always joked to my husband that if we ever got divorced, that’s what we would do.
Little did I know that five years from then, I would leave, and take my two-year-old with me, and my son would never spend another night under the same roof as his father.
Because his dad has never, ever asked for a single night – which really shouldn’t come as a surprise because it’s that complete apathy towards our son and my ex’s paternal duties that is the reason why we left. I would have dearly loved to have an ex who was more involved, who wanted to assert his parental rights. That would have been great for my son. My son deserves that.
Leaving my husband and learning that there are so many good men, so many good dads, out there, has been bittersweet. But after a year or so of trying, post-separation, I realised that I can’t force someone to care.
My ex does, deep down inside, in his own way, love our son. He wouldn’t ever do anything to intentionally hurt him. He doesn’t care enough about either of us to do that.
But that’s the part that creates my dilemma: because if anything ever did happen on his watch, it would be a total accident. It wouldn’t be intentional. So I’m lucky, right? Of course. But there’s a small problem with that: it means I don’t have any real excuse to not allow my son to spend a few hours with him each weekend.
Top Comments
No freakin way would I let my kid be unsupervised with a man who left him alone on the door step or drove drunk with him in the car. Absolutely zero chance.
But the other parent has RIGHTS! If you try to deny his right to have access with his kid, you will be accused of being vindictive, hostile and “parental alienation syndrome” (a completely debunked myth), and custody awarded to the neglectful or abusive parent. Even if you have evidence, even if your kid is terrified of the other parent, even if it is sexual or physical abuse. This is the reality of our family court system that places rights of parent over wellbeing of child.
That’s not apathy, it’s neglectful. It’s illegal to leave a child under 7 directly unsupervised (in NSW at least).
No easy answers with this one, as a protective parent your instincts are to ensure your son is safe first and foremost BUT dad has parental rights (and considering the abuse and neglect out there dad is not all that bad overall) and son wants to see him, but why should you have to risk it until something really bad does happen?
Hopefully as time has passed your son is getting old enough to assume responsibility for his own safety (a key, mobile etc), and perhaps dad might end up re-partnering and she might be willing to ensure dad isn’t neglectful.
I feel for you, it’s a no-win situation.