By Costas Milas, University of Liverpool; George Kyris, University of Birmingham; Remy Davison, Monash University; Richard Holden, UNSW Australia, and Ross Buckley, UNSW Australia
The Greek people have voted, saying a resounding No to the terms of the bailout deal offered by their international creditors. What will this mean for Greece, the euro and the future of the EU? Our experts explain what happens next.
Costas Milas, Professor of Finance, University of Liverpool:
Greek voters have confirmed their support for their prime minister, Alexis Tsipras, who now has the extremely challenging task of renegotiating a “better” deal for his country.
Nevertheless, time is very short. Greece’s economic situation is critical. On July 2, Greek banks reportedly had only €500m in cash reserves. This buffer is not even 0.5% of the €120 billion deposits that Greek citizens have to their names. It is only capital controls preventing Greek banks from collapsing under the strain of withdrawal.
Basic mathematical calculations reveal how desperate the situation is. There are roughly 9.9m registered Greek voters. Assume that – irrespective of whether they voted Yes or No – some 2.8m voters (that is, a very modest 28.2% of the total number of registered voters) decide to withdraw their daily limit of €60 from cash machines on Monday morning. Following this pattern, banks will run out of cash in three days and therefore collapse (note: 3 x 2.8m x 60 ≈ 500m).
Top Comments
I know the writers are experts and I'm not. This is probably why I'm cheering for the Greeks who voted "no". The question is not and has never just been about the law and economics. It is about things like culture and leadership. Germany and France did not attempt to lead the Greeks toward adopting a new cultural value of austerity. They tried to force the issue by using their economic power.
I have been surprised by how much this story has resonated with me. An out of touch federal government driving relatively powerless states towards social and economic ruin through policies of austerity and then I remembered: I live in SA.
For those old enough to remember join in the singing the chorus of Midnight Oil's classic, "it's better to die on your feet than to live on your knees".
Thumbs up.
If you live in SA then you must realise the Government here is heading the same way. It is borrowing money to pay the ever expanding public service, borrowing money to build the new RAH, borrowing money to build an O Bahn extension no-one wants. Where do you think the Government will get the money from to service these loans? The Greek Government used their EU loans to expand their public service (and was the largest employer just like in SA). Greeks consider a job with the public service as akin to winning the lottery. You cannot blame France and Germany for the situation in Greece, although I do blame the EU for admitting countries such as Italy, Spain and Greece who viewed the EU as an ATM machine. The only difference between SA and Greece is at least Greece as a few crumbling old ruins to attract tourists. SA has bugger all.
If you can get other people to pay for your bad decisions then good luck to you and it worked for about a decade as the Greeks falsified their accounts to get into the Euro zone and then used the borrowing power of the EU to build up massive debts that no one would ever have made to the Greek Government - a bit like a teenager being given access to their parent's credit card and ignoring the fact that their only source of income is the casual job at the supermarket. But eventually other people get tired of paying your bills and the money gets cut off. The only reason people are paying any attention to Greece is because of its role as the source of western civilisation - if it were any other corrupt Balkan basket case it would have defaulted long ago and no one would care much as it's a trivial part of the EU. But Spain, Portugal and Italy are much bigger and a default there would be quite serious. So expect the EU to try very hard to make sure that no one gets the message that walking away from your Euro obligations has a happy ending. And even if the German Government didn't have this view there is no way German voters (not to mention the dozen or so EU members who are poorer if better managed than Greece but are still expected to pay for the Greeks) are prepared to tolerate retiring at 67 themselves but pay for the Greeks to retire in their mid 50s.