At 9:30am on Wednesday morning, Cardinal George Pell’s appeal against his child sexual abuse conviction was dismissed. The Court of Appeal sitting in Victoria rejected the centrepiece of Pell’s appeal in a 2-1 decision.
The court determined there was enough evidence to convict Pell of the sexual assault of two choirboys more than 20 years ago.
Following his unsuccessful appeal, Pell will remain in prison and has been sentenced to six years in prison, with a non-parole period of three years and eight months.
Chief Justice Anne Ferguson announces Cardinal George Pell gets appeal dismissed #Pell
— Chris Reason (@ChrisReason7) August 20, 2019
Top Comments
It makes me feel so angry to hear that the defence could try to appeal the appeal of the conviction. He was found guilty by the court, and appealed to a higher court. He was again found guilty, this time in a court of appeal, and is now contemplating appealing again. It is unfair on the victims, their families and friends. A court's decision should have a degree of finality. Of course an accused person should be able to appeal... But this should only be reserved to instances where due process was not followed or the integrity of the judicial system was not upheld. How much more can these victims be expected to tolerate? How much more must the Australian community be forced to put up with? And why on earth, to this day, does the Catholic Church (or at least parts of it) still continue to refuse to disclose admissions of paedophilia in the confessionals? I absolutely understand the importance of requiring proof beyond reasonable doubt. But some people's doubts here are not reasonable. It says proof beyond reasonable doubt, not proof beyond ALL doubt. If you make it so that the only admissible evidence is "hard" evidence then it would make it practically impossible to convict someone of child sex offences. Evidence does not just mean a video or DNA swab. It could include cumulative effects evidence such as testimonies from multiple sources.
Glad he's going to prison.
Disgusted it's only for a maximum of 6 years.