Forget everything you’ve seen in movies about the death penalty. The reality is much worse.
This is my work, these are my days and these people are my clients.
Yes, people like Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran. Men and women who have death hanging over their heads.
It was 2004 when I took on a volunteer role at the Foreign Prisoner Support Service (FPSS) to work on the cases of those people imprisoned, being tortured or kidnapped in countries other than their own.
I can’t say which was the first case to arrive in my inbox as there were simply too many, but forever burnt into my mind from that first week of work is the name Atefeh Rajabi Sahaaleh.
In the cold morning air on August 15th 2004, 16-year-old Atefeh had a noose placed around her neck and in front of a crowd throwing stones, she was hoisted to the sky by a large crane until her neck snapped and faeces ran down her leg.
Lifeless, Atefah swung from the large rope until her body was lowered to the ground. The crowd turned their backs and left to go about their daily business.
Atefeh lived in the Iranian city of Neka and was just 13 when she was raped and tortured by an ex revolutionary guard member Ali Darabi. The abuse lasted three years and was often so bad it left her crawling on all fours.
Ali Darabi, her rapist and torturer, was never accused or convicted of any crime.
Top Comments
Ok so I'm left wing so I guess the assumption is I should be against the death penalty but actually I am on the fence, I actually can empathise with both the for and against arguments.
The problem with this article is that it uses a number of examples where the people were innocent or very likely to be, or examples where people are put to death for doing things that shouldn't be even considerd crimes. Obviously no one in the western world would agree that poor young iranian girl should have been hanged.
However lets take the example of someone who has committed a heinous crime, such as murder, rape, child abuse and that is quite possibly a different story.
The author says that the death penalty is no deterrent against crime but we know that Jill Meagher would still be alive today if her murderer had received the death penalty for his previous result, the fact is he may be released one day and if he is most likely he will rape and possibly murder someone else. There are many other examples of other murderers who have been released and killed again.
People always say that the death penalty is about vengeance when in actual fact I personally have some empathy for some murderers because some of them are seriously screwed up due to terrible childhoods but society's safety I think some of them perhaps need to be put down.
Of course I realise that no matter how clear cut the case seems some people are actually innocent, so from that aspect I could never wholeheartedly support the death penalty.
The other interesting thing is that people against the death penalty often use the example of its cruelty and inhumanity, so what do they purport to be the solution instead for serial killers and other similar crimes? Do we let them go free? Or do we give them life in prison? I'm gathering most anti death penalty supporters would say life in prison or at the very least an extremely lengthy prison sentence. But that is what I find ironic because surely life imprisonment is also barbaric? In actual fact I personally feel more horrified by the thought of life inprosonmebt than the death penalty, of course life imprisonment does mean there is always the chance you will be released, and if you are innocent maybe proof will be found to exonerate you and release, but if I absolutely knew that I would be given life imprisonment I would choose the death penalty. Obviously not everyone would feel the same as me, but I don't think there is anyone who would agree that life imprisonment is a lovely alternative to the death penalty. Both are in humane, but sadly removing dangerous criminals from society is necessary. Whether society decides they are going to opt for the death penalty or life inprosonmebt, the reality is they are both barbaric, but what else option do we have?
What can we do to help in this work?