My Year 8 son gets home, issues a barely perceptible ‘Hi mum’, hurls his ginormous school bag to the floor, yanks open the fridge to look for food, chucks off his school shoes (laces still tied), exchanges the top half of his uniform with a back-to-front tee-shirt and, in this single adolescence dance, somehow manages to take a gulp of water from the kitchen tap.
All the while, he’s maneuvering his iPad from hand to hand, couch to chair to kitchen table, where he does his homework, on, yes, you guessed it, the iPad.
About half an hour later he moves with the clumsy stealth of a labrador to his room, where the iPad proceeds to function as a virtual mall. He plays games, chats with friends, shares 10-most lists, makes videos of himself narrating games and browses PewDiePie on YouTube.
What an intrepid and compact little traveller the ipad is: it’s on the train to school, it’s in the classroom, it’s in the schoolyard and then it’s back on the bus at the end of the day. The ipad may look like an innovative teaching tool, a very ‘moving forward’ education initiative, but the thing comes home every night after school for a sleepover as well!
Top Comments
The school I'm currently doing my teaching prac at issues all students with a laptop (paid for by the students, and they can choose their own brand). This was implemented alongside a strong responsible use of IT policy, which all students have reacted to very well. They are not allowed to open their laptops without permission from their teacher, and must close their screens as soon as a teacher asks. I haven't found it to be detrimental to their learning; in fact, it's been really useful as it means all students can work on their research and assignments in class without having to book a computer room/bank of school laptops. It's especially great for science as I can make use of the multitude of online simulations that can help students learn a lot better than me just talking to them! And very rarely have I seen a student get "distracted" and do something else with their laptop when they should be working - as long as I'm walking around the room keeping an eye on them, they stay on task. The only time I have seen students distracted, they were working on assignments for different classes!
There are also programs like LanSchool where all screens can be monitored from the teacher's computer. Nothing like that look of horror and sheepishness when they're caught out playing games when they should be on task.
Thank you for a positive comment that's not attacking people's parenting. Your classroom sounds well-supervised and the use of device appropriate. That's just not been my experience with my son's school.
Most of his teachers hate them. I had one tell me they are just toys, another say he wanted to throw them all out the window, many more say the students simply don't need them. That's what I mean about the failure to integrate them into the curriculum - at his school, anyway. (Which believe it or not, is academically selective!)
Have these teachers actually tried to incorporate them into the classroom setting? Laptops are probably more ideal for education than iPads, but it's still up to the teachers to at least give them a go. The AITSL Standards require teachers to make use of IT now.
Simple answer? No. And that is the problem. My son had a tablet with a detachable keyboard, so essentially a tiny laptop with Microsoft software. The problem I see is that older teachers in particular are unwilling to adapt to the new standards and the students are taking advantage of the teachers' relative lack of expertise. People talk about filters etc at schools - believe me, kids at my son's school could hack most systems in minutes. Which is why my son is no longer taking his tablet to school.
Well I'm a parent and a teacher too... perhaps if parents parented and made sure that "screen time" at home was monitored and limited and appropriate discussions regarding the use of computer/tablet technology... but no we'll blame schools yet again for the woes of society. If your child is using their BYOD incorrectly in class then perhaps you could talk to them about it... yes that would require parenting as well. Personal responsibility for learning is important, self control and restraint are skills learnt and refined at home. School students actually spend more time at home than at school - perhaps Elly you could try actually taking the tablet when he comes home and engage him in a conversation. I don't necessarily believe that BYOD is great, in fact I get frustrated every day by its use but... it is a tool that can be effective in learning. The problem is the unfettered use of it at home, its use to be constantly in communique with others through social media, it's use to bully and intimidate others from home, it's ability to allow kids to watch and access whatever they want from inside their home behind closed doors, its ability to allow kids to play games online all night behind closed doors and then fall asleep in class all the while their parents are unaware of what their children are up too. This is the problem not its use at school.
OK, so as a teacher, tell me how you've integrated the use of a device in your classroom in a way that is actually meaningful, not just googling crap or playing supposedly educational games?
'googling crap' - is that how you define doing meaningful research for assessment tasks? Okay then. I use programs like Kahoot to develop topic tests at the end of a unit of work. Every student needs a device to access this program. There is also presentations - the use of Prezi, Google Slides and Powerpoint enable a student to do a multi modal presentation. My students set up websites accessed by their peers so they learn collaboratively. Is that enough for you? This is just a small sample. You clearly have no idea what REALLY goes on
So you teach in my son's school, do you? I am speaking from my experience as a parent, not generalising for all. You clearly have no idea what goes on in other teachers' classrooms. And having completed a PhD, I know exactly what constitutes meaningful research. I see teachers encouraging students to use Wikipedia as a primary source. Enough said.
So you're regularly in your child's classroom and witness them encouraging the use of Wikipedia? Okay. You asked a question and I answered and now you're making it all about you. If you feel technology is not being adequately used in your own child's school then you should take it up with administration, not whinge and moan.