Speculation about the mental health of the man who crashed Germanwings flight 9525 mustn’t taint the way we see those living with depression.
Trigger warning: This post deals with issues of self-harm, depression and suicide and some readers may find it triggering.
Mental illness happens to people who are living ordinary, good lives, just like my family and me when I first became ill at the age of 16.
Without warning, I woke up one day with a firm belief that I was sapping oxygen from the world and would be better off dead. At first I thought everyone had similar experiences, but by the time I turned 19, life had become a kind of black horror when awake and back-to-back nightmares when asleep. There was no reprieve.
Depression is a barren well, deep and dark, and I was alone at the bottom of it and there was no light from the top so I couldn’t see beyond my own suffering. After weeks, months, years in the well, I lost even the basest urges of life: hunger, thirst, sleep, libido, hygiene, health, social contact, order. Time stretched as a desert does – distant, uncharted, wide and flat as ice. I couldn’t concentrate on anything, I couldn’t even read a magazine or watch TV. My brain was like a stopped clock. I walked around with a grief-like ache in my chest as though all my loved ones had died at once.
What can we learn from the Germanwings tragedy, where the co-pilot Andreas Lubitz was reported to have been suffering from depression? First, though depressive symptoms may have made up part of Lubitz’s mental state at the time, depression (or any other kind of mental illness) is not solely to blame. There is no established link between depression and violence towards others. People with depression do not pose a danger to others as a result of their illness.
Top Comments
Finally a voice of reason. Just because someone is depressed, even seriously depressed, doesn't mean they plan to commit homicide. And the reality is this is what he did. If he had said to a counsellor/doctor etc that he wanted to kill lots of people then I think that would be more pertinent then if he wanted to commit suicide. Also someone can be suicidal and depressed at one stage in their life but later in life be fine, does this mean if 20 years ago someone confessed to suicidal thoughts that they should be dismissed as a pilot. Even if this was 1 month ago it doesn't mean they plan to kill a lot of people.
I have felt suicidal a few times in my life and never would I have contemplated killing others, at the time I was in pain and felt suicide may be a way of ending that pain, I certainly didn't wish to inflict pain on others, if anything I would have wanted people to have remembered me affectionately not with horror and disgust. Oh and by the way I don't feel suicidal now and I am very good at my job. Interestingly I was doing my job just as well when I felt suicidal, as when I was on the job I was totally focused, it was only when I was alone I was having these thoughts due to a personal drama that was happening in my life at the time. I certainly didn't tell my employer as it is none of their business, and as much as I like my employer I'm not that naive to think that they are all going to be sympathetic and wrap me up in cotton wool, at the end of the day they are running a business and you are only as good to an employer as you are productive.
I'm any case whatever this pilot was planning it doesn't matter how many assessments he had it doesn't mean he would have necessarily told someone, most people who plan murder don't go around confessing this beforehand.
I think the problem we have in western society is we want every tragedy to be avoidable and when some tragedy occurs we want someone to be held accountable, so everyone is trying to blame the airline. I would hold the airline accountable if he told them he was planning to fly a plane into a mountain, but he didn't and as airlines can't read minds it's not their fault.
We need to understand that some tragedies can't be averted and just resign ourselves to that fact because the way society is heading if someone trips on a twig in the national park and dies then the next thing is we will hold the national parks responsible for not clearing all of the twigs out of the park.
I think it was a combination of elements coming together with the opportunity to act.
It seems like he felt a very, very deep lack of worth, self-esteem and control in his life but masked it obsessively. He managed to 'take full control' in this situation, possibly 'pay back' society in general for whatever damage he aligned with them (maybe going back years) and be remembered infamously. As sick as that is, I think this may have been his line of thinking. But, I'm no psychologist.