Perhaps I too was like you… curious to make sense of how a life so full of potential ends so unexpectedly.
But now that I’ve been widowed for 5+ years, I know the “how” doesn’t matter. Not to me, and not to anyone who has experienced a devastating loss.
If it came from a legitimate place of concern then we’d be less bothered. But often, it’s asked with little to no sympathy or empathy—just a morbid fascination in wanting to know how someone died. I see it all the time.
A high school classmate shares a post announcing the passing of a parent only to be greeted with “How did she pass?” Unless you – random acquaintance who probably have never taken the time to even ask how’s she’s holding up – are asking because you’re wondering if her parent’s death is a result of a zombie apocalypse that you might have missed while you were busy scanning for R.I.P. posts on social media, then it’s not appropriate.
You don’t have the right to ask for details of someone’s death. So it was cancer…now what? They died in an accident…how does this affect YOU?
Top Comments
I don’t really agree with this. I prefer to be asked questions about my lost loved one, as it then feels like he still exists / matters to someone other than me. I’d rather be asked about his life, sure, but at least when people ask about his death it’s better than them avoiding the subject altogether which is what most people do.
I guess the takeaway is that everyone in grief needs something different...
Sounds like she’s still working through the process of grieving and still very angry 😪 I’m not sure how much advice she should be giving
I agree. I’ve sadly lost more people than most have by my age, and I’d have to say that this whole issue is one which is both deeply personal and also extremely confusing for those “looking on”. Many people, for example, are not religious and would take deep offence at being offered prayers from friends; many friends, afraid of doing or saying the “wrong” thing, will say nothing.
Which is what some people in mourning prefer, whereas others just need people to say something, anything.
The “how?” question is, in my experience, coming from a place of shock and/or caring, especially if the asker knew the deceased and are now suddenly facing a loss of their own (which they have to process in their own way). They’ll want also to know how to treat you; for example, it’s no good saying “at least their suffering is at an end” if the person wasn’t in the throws of a terminal illness.
Then there’s the natural question we all ask ourselves as to why someone who was so loved could die, especially if they’re the same age as us/our grandma etc...don’t our minds all go straight away to “Oh gosh, that would be like MY daughter dying...” I’m not saying this is of any comfort to those left behind (well, good for you Sally, your daughter isn’t an *insert something here* so you’re off the hook), just that it’s almost instinctual.