It’s hard to write about one particular criticism against men that we need to move away from when, unequivocally, the criticisms aimed at women are far more severe.
When women are being attacked online, they’ve reported fearing for their lives and the lives of their families. They receive death threats, rape threats, and, if their online assailant is feeling mild, they’re called dumb, ugly, fat whores.
When men are criticised, the conversation is far more likely to actually stick to what they’ve said or what they’ve done, and while it can still be vitriolic, they’re not torn apart to the same extent as their female peers.
But oppression isn’t as simple as men versus women. It’s just not. Certain rhetoric hurts us all, and particular perceptions and arguments do more harm than good.
Like the currently popular insult: manbaby. A man who gets angry and upset. A man who is too sensitive. A man who is vulnerable.
Often, the insinuation is that these men feel they’ve been mistreated by women, or are hurt by something women experience far more often. Which, yes, is extremely infuriating to watch.
Last night, writer Clementine Ford posted an apology to radio host Ben Fordham for unintentionally misrepresenting a conversation they had in a recent column.
2GB host Ben Fordham. Image: Instagram
The majority of the comments left on the Facebook post were, simply put, horrible. They were vile against Ford. They were aggressive towards other commenters. They were nasty about Fordham.
And it's here I noticed how unhelpful and potentially problematic the 'manbaby' insult is. These were some of the comments:
Top Comments
I think if you regress to calling someone a manbaby or a baby or whatever names, then you've really lost the argument. Surely people are able to debate at a higher level than insulting one another?
Except for old white males right? They are terrible and anything they think or feel is invalid because of their skin colour.
My point with the old, straight, conservative, rich white males is simply that they dominate every facet of public life - overwhelmingly! Which means everyone else is not represented in any meaningful way - women, Intersex, youth, LGBTIQ, poor, non-White etc. And the ruling demographic continue to make decisions that benefit and enrich themselves and their old school tie mates. It's ludicrous.
Stop using old white rich conservative men's electricity, petrol and internet if you feel they are somehow operating unfairly. Stay off planes as well and put your medicines in the bin. Or, you could acknowledge that it's wrong and unfair to ignore individuals and treat them instead as part of a demographic. Who ever voted for us to willingly lose our unique identity? Try to treat people as they come, not as some rank on your victim scale.
What? I stand by my comments.
I used to belong to the 'man up', 'grow a pair' brigade...until my son tried to kill himself. I consider myself a feminist but I don't belong to that brigade anymore.
Wow, that's an incredibly harsh way to learn that lesson. I hope your son is doing OK now.