Last night’s television was sobering for anyone with a vagina.
On the Sunday Night show the excellent Melissa Doyle was talking body image with two very different women.
They agreed on one thing: Women hating their bodies is holding them back.
After that, things were messy.
In one corner there was Ashy Bines: fitness guru, Instagram sensation, creator of a 12-week Bikini Body challenge, nominated leader of a cult populated by women with French braids and brightly-patterned activewear.
In the other, Taryn Brumfitt: body image guru, Facebook sensation, creator of a documentary called Embrace which focuses on all the ways that being obsessed with our bodies is screwing up women and damaging their lives.
These women are both exceptionally smart and exceptionally ambitious about the spreading of their message.
They come from the same place: A concern that the way women feel about themselves is deeply, intrinsically entwined with the way they feel about their bodies.
And then their paths drastically diverge.
Because in Ashy's world, the mantra is this: If you don't like it, change it.
Saggy bum? Mum tum? Stop eating that, start doing this. Ashy runs the Booty World Tour to reduce and then pump up women's bums, en masse. She uses her own remarkable body as branding for a movement that is best described as 'Stop whingeing and get off your arse'.
Top Comments
Why do we have to pick a team? Surely we can all accept the me we are now while working towards improving those things that really cause us to struggle with accepting ourselves.
I'm a very large girl, I haven't always been that way so right now I accept that is what I have to live with, RIGHT NOW. I also acknowledge that it is one of my main causes for depression and am working on improving my diet and fitness to bring my size down to something I can accept long term. This will not be an overnight or "12 week" process, this will be a lifelong commitment to my health and well being.
I've tried 12 week challenges, 8 week body turnarounds, shake diets, exclusion diets, fast/juice cleanses even the 80/20 diet they all seem so great when you start out and loose those first few kilos. But lets be honest here, people like Ashy (who probably have exceptional genetics helping them in ways my genes never could) have created their business/wealth by omitting 1 small fact from their marketing. The 12 weeks is not enough. Unless you're prepared to commit to lifelong changes your results will not be permanent.
Maybe it's time we stop reading all the toxic magazine articles about why we should be ashamed of our jiggling this or that, unfollow all those "before and after" "fitspo" accounts, stop worrying what other people think, get over ouselves a little and sign back into the real world.
Yay pitting women against each other simply for having different views! That's what feminism was made for....
To be honest I've got on foot either side, I go to gym and ride to work a. for health and fitness and b. because I want to feel hot in a bikini. But I'm going to do something neither of these women are doing and focus on myself not tell other women how they should feel/look! If we all did that I think we'd all get along nicely.
I'm with you...Heaven forbid a women be fit and slim AND embrace the "accept your body and be ok with it movement".