A five-year old boy has been billed for a no show at a friend’s birthday party resulting in threats of legal action.
It’s tough being a kid these days.
Back in our day the biggest scandal surrounding a birthday party was when only six girls were invited to Annabel Bett’s 7th’s “P” party. It was heartbreaking knowing all the gang were dressed as Punky Brewster while I sat at home rearranging my swap cards.
These days a birthday party fiasco makes headlines right around the world even before the parents involved manage to brief their lawyers.
Overnight the story of a five-year old boy who was invoiced for not showing up at a “friend’s” party ( lets’ face it there is no way these mums are getting together for a playdate and mini muffins any time in the near future) has made every major news organisation and lit up social media.
The boy, a five-year old cutie from Cornwall in the UK came home last week from school with a an invoice in his school bag for ditching another child’s party.
Alex’s Mum Tanya had accepted the invite and Alex had told his mate he was keen to go.
Happy days.
The festivities included a snow-tube ride and a hot birthday meal with ice cream or jelly.
(Whatever happened to pin-the-tail on the donkey and fairy bread?)
Top Comments
I think everyone is agreed that it's poor form to ditch a party on the day. I disagree that it's the heinous crime most seem to think it is - it's happen to me with my kids' parties plenty of times, my kids are so giddy with having the remainder of their friends there plus, you know, the whole PARTY, that they're not too distressed by it. So I'd hazard a guess that Party Boy in this story has managed to put it behind him as well.
I'll also confess that I've done it - I have completely forgotten to take my child to a party we had previously RSVPed to. Surprisingly not because I'm an evil dictator who eats kittens for breakfast, but because I'm a mere human whose brain is somewhat less disciplined and orderly than a German automobile.
Now, the bit that bothers me is that this is a social transaction. So while No Show Boy is in the wrong (mildly...family tends to trump other commitments for most people) and has committed a social faux pas, and if Party Boy's Mummy feels a response is needed (that is, she doesn't "do" forgiveness), then that response should be in kind. Ie, social. Instead, she is trying to turn a social transaction into a financial one, which is 28 kinds of crazy but, I suspect, a sign of the consumerist, money-grubbing society we have become.
She has also issued the invoice for a No Show, which she had to pay for. However, and this is the kicker, she would have paid for him if he has been a Show. So the ONLY person to have missed out on an item of financial worth is No Show. Party Boy may also have suffered some emotional (social) hardship. Party Boy's Mummy paid the same amount, whether all children attended or not.
To turn around and dish out financial penalties after the fact is nuts. She is not a business, or a court, or the UN imposing sanctions on a West African dictatorship. However, if we lived in a world where it was acceptable to put a price tag on our social interactions (perhaps we already do), then the least she would need to do is charge all attendees up front for their partcipation - ie. pop an invoice in with the invite. Or, if pursuing someone in Small Claims is a likely outcome, then she should at least warn invitees that they are liable to cough up for non-attendance, and that acceptance of the invitation also constitutes financial consent to being invoiced. Complicated, yes, but if social transactions are to become financial, at least give the other side a sporting chance. It is absolutely tacky in the extreme, but if that's the way we're headed, then at least get it right.
Or, you know, do what you can afford, and be an honest, kind, forgiving sort of person, raising non-litigious, non-invoice-brandishing children. That is an option too.
Forget the money. The bigger issue is that a parent has gone to a lot of effort to try and give their child a day they will love and remember and then are faced with other people apologetically disappointing their child on that day. The invoice is crazy but not caring about the feelings of a child on their birthday is worse.