Tara Brown, you nailed it.
You bloody nailed it.
That’s what I wanted to say last night when I watched Tara Brown conduct one of the most horrific and disturbing interviews I’ve ever seen on television. I am of course talking about the interview on Sixty Minutes with David and Wendy Farnell – otherwise known as Baby Gammy’s biological parents.
I think every Australian wanted answers as to how any parent could abandon their child overseas – to an impoverished Thai surrogate, no less. Australians wanted answers too, to claims of child sex convictions, paedophilia, jail time for those crimes.
And Tara got those answers for us.
Make no mistake it wasn’t an easy interview to watch. But Tara made the unwatchable watchable as she calmly, systematically dismantled the arguments put forth.
TARA BROWN: As a child sex offender, as a convicted child sex offender, what right do you have to have access to young children?DAVID FARNELL: Well, I’ve been convicted of, yeah, child sex offences, and I hang my head in shame for that. And I am deeply regretful for that. And I’m so, so sorry to those people.
TARA BROWN: And it wasn’t just one, was it?
DAVID FARNELL: …
TARA BROWN: I mean, it is people.
DAVID FARNELL: …
TARA BROWN: Many people that you have to apologise to.
DAVID FARNELL: Yes. So…
WENDY FARNELL: It’s OK. It’s past.
DAVID FARNELL: Yeah, OK. So yeah, I was convicted and I went to jail. And when I got out of jail I thought, “Well, I can run and hide and change my name and move to another town.” But I thought, “No, I need to face everybody and I can say, yes, I’m taking responsibility for what I did.” So I stayed, I stayed in Bunbury. I copped abuse, I copped a lot of horrible things, but I stayed there and I faced it. And I said that I will continue until I can hold my head up high again. And I think that I have done that.
TARA BROWN: When did you learn to be remorseful? Because the judge at the time said that you showed no remorse and that through counselling you tried to minimise your crime. When did it hit you that you actually did do the wrong thing?
DAVID FARNELL: I think just seeing my children and thinking that if somebody did that to my children I would be devastated.
TARA BROWN: But you had children when you did it, didn’t you?
But Tara Brown brought her A-game last night. She was fierce, she was unrelenting and she wasn’t going home until she had the answers every Australian has asked themselves over the past few weeks since this story broke.
And it got me thinking last night. When I was growing up and talk turned to the amazing achievements of female journalists … Jana (Wendt) and Ita (Buttrose) always headed the list but then there’d be a pause and names like Barbara Walters and Diane Sawyer and Oprah Winfrey took over. We had to sort of look outside of Australia for big names in terms of female journalism.
Top Comments
Sally Sara. A great ABC Foreign correspondent. Did Afghanistan when it was war-time scary, Africa, and lots more besides. And has a magnificent bone dry sense of humour on twitter.
Great article, great interview but enough now. I refuse to believe the surrogate mother does not want anything from all this media coverage. I just hope Gammy isn't abandoned again when she realises she isn't getting a cent.
I agree. Enough of this now. And quite honestly, I find it lame. Interview them, sure. But to use it to 'systematically dismantle the arguments' of two people who combined do not have the media training, education or moral compass to answer unanswerable questions by Tara is lazy. She was ALWAYS going to dismantle their argument because an ape could dismantle their argument. Yes, interview these two people if you must, but not as a bulldozer. Get to the core problem with your bulldozer-y: The organisations facilitating this in the first place. These two were easy hate targets, and distractions from the larger problem.
I thought she did a great job. I have run media training for various organisations and it was clear they had been given some prior media training basics (most likely from whichever law firm they have been talking too) as classic elements of basic elements of trying to sell your story were there (eye contact, even tone. Step and repeat your key story) The main problem is that their story is sh!t to begin with, no amount of media training can fix that... I thought consider how easy it would have been to take the popular rout and tear them to shreds and shame them, Tara did a great job of keeping her tone and presentation even whilst still not accepting their rather dubious claims and contradictory story.
I'll agree she kept her cool, and her tone, but it was just a passive aggressive bulldozing of two people who are one part of a bigger story. She did tear them to shreds and shame, she just did it with an even temper. She knew they're story was easily dismantled, and passively pulled it apart in front of a nation-wide audience. Why the kudos? As you said, no amount of media training can fix their story, so why pitchfork it anyway and move audience focus away from what is actually playing out? All the outrage to the easiest target.