So… This is awkward.
Turns out the guy who did all the signing for the deaf community at Nelson Mandela’s funeral was totally faking it.
Like, actually faking it. He was just standing up on stage, while world leaders were giving heartfelt speeches, waving his arms around completely nonsensically.
Basically the equivalent of Barack Obama getting up there and just speaking gibberish.
Nobody knows his name or where he came from. They’ve been calling him The Fake Interpreter. This is him (to the right, saying “ksjdgb ksjdbg aiurar sdhfc aeaf kljdhg purple monkey dishwasher”):
This is a video (via UK deaf news website Limping Chicken) of The Fake Interpreter signing compared with an actual professional who, you know, knows how to sign:
So WTF happened? How did this guy think he would get away with it? Obviously the deaf community were going to notice that his ‘interpretation’ was more of the dance variety than the official sign language variety.
The “Um… What’s up with THIS guy?” tweets starting coming thick and fast. Wilma Newhoudt, the first ever deaf member of South Africa’s parliament, was one of the first notice:
ANC linked interpreter cannot sign at all, he’s making up signs. Please get him off
— wilma newhoudt (@newhoudt) December 10, 2013
Top Comments
Sadly this reflects South Africa in many ways. Quality & standards are just not that important to the government of the day. In fact, this can be used as analogy for so many things being covered up, smoothed over and hoping for the best.
"If what I had been interpreting was wrong all these years, why should it become an issue now?" Fake Interpreter says in an interview published in The Age today http://m.theage.com.au/worl...
Eerie parallels between that statement and the approach to governing followed by the ANC post-Mandela.
This Jimmy Kimmel Live video where an actual professional sign language translator translates what Fake Interpreter Thamsanqa Jantjie really 'said' during the memorial shows that schizophrenia was not the issue here (a fact that has been confirmed by psychiatrists who made it clear that Jantjies's way of translating was not reminiscent of people with schizophrenia: http://m.youtube.com/watch?...
"Deaf community" needs a capital. And if you check out the Jimmy Kimmel video, the guy was signing words, they just made no sense together. So he wasn't signing adjdljwrcbskao, because sign language is primarily signs for words, not letters. I found this a little offensive
What group is this offensive to? The Fake sign language community? It seems to me like an innocent mistake regarding the nature of this man's deception, not a slur on those who practice sign language correctly. By all means, correct a factual error when you see one - that is how we learn from each other - but I wish people wouldn't jump so quickly to claim offense whenever somebody gets something slightly wrong.