What if we could stop people dying by suicide? Better yet, how about getting world leaders to actually try?
The Deputy Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, Nick Clegg, has pledged to eliminate suicide. Not reduce it, not minimise those at risk, but actually stop suicide. Entirely.
Zero suicides? As in, no further suicides in the British patient population? It’s ambitious. Ooph, yeah, it’s ambitious.
But it’s also possible.
In fact, it’s been done before. The people of Detroit, USA, achieved exactly this 6 years ago.
16 suicide warning signs. And what to do next.
In 2001, the Henry Ford Health System developed what was called the Perfect Depression Plan. The plan was a total overhaul of the mental health system to ensure that patients did not fall through the cracks. It was a comprehensive restructure designed to protect people at risk, give them access to the beds, the care and the professionals they needed.
By 2008, they had succeeded. They got to zero. For the duration of that year, there were no patient suicides in a city of 700,000 people. To put that in context, depending on what figures you use the usual rate of patient suicide in the United States is around 34 per 100,000 – so that’s 248 people who might otherwise have taken their own lives. Impressive.
Nick Clegg wants to replicate this success in England.
He’s one of the only politicians who in the world treating suicide as the international emergency it is. Wherever the hell on the political spectrum he sits, Clegg has got this much right: “Suicide is, and always has been, a massive taboo in our society. People are genuinely scared to talk about it, never mind intervene when they believe a loved one is at risk”.
Top Comments
Unfortunately you might as well as say lets stop death. Cut the bullshit. You can't stop death. People kill themselves for various reasons. Just so you know, the world's population is close to 8 billion people.
A friend of mine committed suicide last week. He had made a doctors appointment to talk to a professional about his depression, but sadly he didn't make it to the appointment. One of the hardest things about his funeral for me was hearing people say. 'if only he could have just made it to his appointment none of this would have happened'. The problem is, while I can't speak for him, I'm not entirely sure that's true. When I had pneumonia last year I saw a doctor and felt considerably better within hours after the appointment after being prescribed antibiotics. Within a week I was back to normal. It took me a lot of courage to finally talk to a doctor about my depression in 2012. Now, almost 2 and a half years later, I honestly can't say I am in a better position mentally than I was before I walked into my doctor's office the first time. No matter how often I tell health professionals that I really haven't gotten any better, none of them take it seriously enough. They say things like 'I can imagine that would be hard for you', but all that ever happens is they switch me to a new medication or increase my dosage and tell me to make an appointment in 6 weeks and see if things have improved. I have had at least 15 doctors appointments related to my depression in these 2 and a half years, and to be completely honest it's been a massive waste of my time and tax payers' money. It's fantastic that no one in Detroit killed themselves in 2008. It doesn't change the fact that thousands of people in Detroit that year were still miserable enough to want to kill themselves, and that untold amounts of people all over the world still are.
You know I read this article and I felt hesitant about the zero suicide idea, I wasn't sure why because on the face of it it seems like a good idea, but your response has made me realise why I was hesitant, because as you have mentioned the focus needs to be on making people happier, if they have been prevented committing suicide but still miserable it's not really a success.
I do hope though you find some happy solution to your problem, I can't think of anything to say that would be more effective than the professionals have said to you, but i do hope you find some happiness, your post is well thought out, without knowing you I am sure you are not a waste of tax payers dollar, you probably contribute to society and are valued by many who love and appreciate you.
Thank you, Anon. Your kind words really do mean a lot to me. I think the reason why doctors don't always treat my condition with the seriousness I'd like is because I still manage to hold down a full-time job and live (what on the surface probably appears to be) a normal life. It's frustrating that it seems to take falling off the edge to really grab their attention because, like in the case of my friend, sometimes by the time they're ready to take you seriously it's too late.
Hi hayley, I never comment on stuff but your post sure grabbed my attention. I've suffered depression most of my life and was in a similar position as u a couple of years ago. I had no hope, plagued with bad thoughts, felt worthless and suicidal and had a meltdown and had to take time off my full time job.thankfully I had more understanding docs than it seems u had. My issue was the opposite of yours in that I thought I shouldnt be so depressed, I had a full time job (though I didn't like it much) family that loved and supported me, a roof over my head and savings in the bank. I had nothing to be depressed about so why was I. My doctors convinced me that everyone reacts differently and your problems are no less important than the person who has no job, no family etc. My advice to u is that u need to find better doctors and you do need to go to more sessions than 15 in 2 years. I was going weekly for the 1st 8 months or so after my meltdown. It's not cheap but it's your health. Plus what helped me is medication and finding the right mixture. It did take a painful 12 months or so to get the right cocktail of drugs that lifted my depression fog draped over me, but it finally happen. I have also found routine physical exercise was a great way to put order into the chaos. Perservere with your sessions and medication. U sound like u want to heal so keep at it and get through 1 day at a time. take care
Hi Amy, thanks for your comment. I think actually we are in quite similar boats (full-time jobs, family, a roof over our heads, savings etc) I have just had a lot of trouble finding a good doctor. I've been to several different clinics, but going to a new one is like starting over from scratch for me. The reason why I've only had approximately 15 visits (maybe closer to 20) is that I'm always told to trial a new medication/dosage for 6 weeks then book another appointment, and because I've seen at least 4 doctors at 3 different clinics (off the top of my head) I'm wondering where else to go. I find it hard because a lot of the time doctors seem to want me to hone in on an area of my life I want to improve (a bad relationship, bad finances, family problems etc), but like you I don't have a specific problem causing my depression, it's the depression that is the problem. I will keep at it. But thank you very much for your message, I too have found physical exercise to be a great way to put order into the chaos as you put it, and I find it really reassuring to hear about people in my situation who've gotten through it.