In May last year, an Animals Australia investigation went to air on Four Corners exposing the abuse of cattle in Indonesian slaughterhouses. A huge public outcry followed and it brought about an abrupt (albeit short) termination of live cattle exports to Indonesia pending investigation.
Many of us who saw that footage probably thought something along the lines of “Thank God that didn’t happen to the steaks I buy”. Well, unfortunately, you can’t be absolutely sure of that.
(You can watch some of that footage here)
In late 2011, Animals Australia circulated footage of abattoir workers in Gippsland, Victoria, inflicting gross acts of cruelty to pigs during their slaughter. The footage was so damning that the abattoir was shut down. Fast-forward four months and another animal rights group, Animal Liberation, has captured workers in a NSW slaughterhouse beating fully conscious pigs to death, skinning sheep alive and enacting other horrifying acts of cruelty on goats and cattle.
The covert footage taken in both cases has finally brought to light an issue that is rumoured to be widespread throughout the meat processing industry.
Comments from the NSW Food Authority stating that these are ‘rogue operators’ is not suitable justification for resisting calls to install 24-hour CCTV in all Australian abattoirs. Better than catching the people who inflict this treatment upon animals, let’s use CCTV to prevent it from occurring in the first place.
After similar footage was aired in the United Kingdom in 2010 there was an enormous outcry across the country. They, too, were horrified that the animals being slaughtered for their consumption were enduring such extreme cruelty and they petitioned their supermarkets. As a result, many of the largest supermarkets in the UK stopped buying meat from processors that didn’t use CCTV and allow it to be monitored by independent animal welfare groups.
Top Comments
No one wants to see animals being abused; the majority of farmers and abboitoir operators for whom animals are their livelihood do not want to see it and know that the best way to maintain this livelihood is to look after animals. CCTV footage may be an answer but we need to also ask how we will fund these measures (this footage will surely need to be reviewed by an expert on a randomised basis) because supermarkets will not absorb them and ultimately farmers will not be able to afford to look after animals or farm the, and we will all need to buy our meat from Indonesia. Broad brush statements such as 'we are no better here!!!' are decisive and unhelpful. Please be respectful of good farmers and good operators in the industry and you may find people in the industry may also have some good strategies to combat the few poor ones.
Hi Jo,
I agree. I understand that farmers who work our often treacherous land often put their heart and soul into it - who would endure those conditions if not for the love of it!? I know (and buy for my family despite being vegan myself) meat that's sourced direct from the farm. I know where it was produced and I know where it was processed. I also know that a butcher who buys the whole animal can see very clearly if the animal has been mistreated during slaughter. It is important to buy from a butcher that takes enough pride in what they do to report it back to the farmer. The problem? There just isn't very much choice for farmers when it comes to meat processing. Their often hogtied; having to deal with the back practices in case they are blacklisted and have to drive their animals an extra god-knows-how-many hours to the next slaughterhouse.
It's a quandary - no doubt about it.
Sarahx
Sad to think of the animals getting slaughtered if they suffer ....sad!