Her family say she was trying to help him. Prosecutors say she urged him to take his own life.
Warning: This post contains details of suicide and may be very distressing and difficult for some readers. If you need help please phone Lifeline on 13 11 14.
It is the first case of its kind – a teenager charged with involuntary manslaughter for allegedly encouraging her boyfriend to suicide.
The teenager, 18-year-old Michelle Carter, from Massachusetts, in the US, is said to have urged her boyfriend Conrad Roy, also 18 to take his own life.
The relationship between the two – though they referred to each other as “boyfriend” and “girlfriend” was largely online.
They met two years before Conrad’s death – speaking mainly over the Internet and via text message.
According to court documents the relationship was secret from many who knew them, even Conrad’s best friend was unaware of it.
In more than 1,000 messages between the two police have argued that Michelle urged Conrad to take his own life.
One particularly chilling message stands out.
The Washington Post reports that at one stage when 18-year old Conrad told his girlfriend he was scared and had gotten out of the truck where he would later be found dead. She responded: “Get back in.”
Her family say that Michelle – a straight A student is being painted unfairly as a villain and she just tried to help Carter.
“She is a quiet, kind, and sympathetic young girl. She tried immensely to help Mr. Roy in his battle with depression. We know that once all of the facts are released, our daughter will be found innocent.”
Top Comments
This is completely awful and yet, I don't know if she should be on the hook for manslaughter.
Teenagers really have no concept of death and they love drama ... plus she was very removed from him as a human being - did they even meet F2F? it seems like it was just an online relationship?
Maybe he made her promise to not let him back out of it and in some misguided dumb teenage girl way she thought she was helping him.
Maybe she thought it was romantic - social media & the media have romanticised death a lot - tweeting a cool statement about someones death has become a 'thing' - we see tweets published like an anthology when someone dies - couldn't a teenage girl potentially fantasise that it would be romantic to have your boyfriends death to tweet and post about?
I just feel like encouraging someone to do something isn't a crime - if I encourage someone to murder someone would I be held responsible? I'm not sure.
You should definitely be held responsible for encouraging someone to murder another person. Charles Manson never actually killed anyone himself- he convinced his followers do do it instead.
The absolute telling part of this story is the girl asking him to delete her texts. She absolutely knew she was doing the wrong thing. Kids are taught so much now about the power of peer pressure & depression, it does not seem reasonable that she did not have the capability to know this situation was not right. This girl is 18, not 8.
While I agree that some teenagers romanticise situations like this and thrive on drama- someone that would go as far as to do this comes more under the umbrella of mental illness than "dumb teenager."
yes you would be held responsible, it's called an accomplice! Accomplice, by definition is. One who knowingly, voluntarily, and with common intent unites with the principal offender in the commission of a crime. One who is in some way concerned or associated in commission of crime; partaker of guilt; one who aids or assists, or is an Accessory
I am nearly sick reading this. This beautiful young man is dead and his family will feel that loss for the rest of their lives.
What a truly vile and disgusting human being she is.