by KATHY KRUGER
I wanted to share something very personal – a letter I wrote to our daughter’s birthmother seven years ago. I wrote it as I reflected on how lucky we are to have our daughter (even luckier now to have our son also).
At the time an adoptive mother was trying to organise an anthology of letters with the hope of publishing them in China and the hope that birth mothers there might actually read them and find some consolation in the sentiments. Unfortunately the project, as far as I know, didn’t proceed.
I’ve had many thoughts and feelings about our daughter’s birthmother since. I’ve hoped dearly that the pain of her loss has lessened with time and I’ve felt privileged that our joy in being parents has only deepened with the years. I’ve felt guilt and sadness and pride and joy, but this letter captures a point in time when I reflected very clearly on how loss is so central to adoption, and how, after all the sadness, gain is really the only thing we can take out of it.
Here is the letter:
She’s beautiful, just like you. Her dark eyes sparkle like diamonds, just like yours. Her smile lights up her face and the lives of those around her. She radiates. Her laughter gives happiness a sound.
She’s the master of the cheeky, winking grin. Her wonder and awe at the world is like an exclamation mark on her face. She looks like a little imp when she screws up her nose in that funny way that makes me smile.
Top Comments
I sincerely hope that you adequately investigated the circumstances of your daughter's placement in adoption. Many children of parents who have been caught violating China's one child policy are placed in adoption without the consent of their parents. They are sold to white couples as an income stream for the abusive Chinese government. Please be aware that you may be supporting grave human rights abuses when engaging in international adoption.
Yes I think we did investigate, as best we could, the circumstances of our daughter (and later son) being placed for international adoption in China. I know that I have learned a lot more since we adopted our daughter in 2004 that have given me more insight into the complexities of the situation and human rights abuses that do occur. Our adoption was handled in an extremely professional and comprehensive manner through the Queensland Government, Australian Government and directly to the China Centre for Adoption Affairs, a Chinese Government Agency under an inter-country agreement and terms of the Hague Convention. I don't pretend to understand everything about Chinese government policy or social issues - I have tried to inform myself. The one child policy is not as simplistic as is often perceived, or as you have implied. It applies in different ways in different provinces and rural areas, with families often allowed two children if they have a daughter first. We followed due process and adopted in good faith. A couple of years after our daughter's adoption evidence came to light of corruption within the Chinese adoption system - the Chinese government appeared to take reasonable action, suspending inter-country adoption for a period. Since then the number of children being adopted out of China has declined dramatically - due to a number of factors including improved economic conditions, increased domestic adoption within China (a good thing) and quite possibly an ongoing crackdown on any corrupt practices (another very good thing). The program now almost exclusively places special needs children who are difficult for find families within China and are clearly vastly better off with access to better medical care out of the orphanage environment (care we also support through donations). As you know China is a huge country, with many contradictions, a significant gender imbalance that has led to a major domestic human trafficking problem. I certainly don't pretend to have any answers.
Fine, maybe their parents were political prisoners. Are you more comfortable with that? Our government has a vested economic interest in keeping the Chinese happy and ignoring their gross human rights violations. The Chinese government obviously isn't going to be upfront about where their children come from.
Go Kathy!
Please ignore the detractors - there are hundreds of reasons why parents give up children but the reality is children are not ALWAYS better off with their birth parents. My sisters & I were adoptees and we count ourselves blessed.
Thanks for loving those precious children.
Thank you GJ - I'm glad you and your sisters have had positive adoptions.